78–15 and 67–5: Japan's Rugby Thrashings Were Probably Inevitable

England 78, Japan 15. Scotland 67, Japan 5.

What Japan’s national rugby team ran into on this tour of Britain wasn’t just a defeat. It was a gap in ability against the world’s best that nothing could bridge.

I knew watching was pointless, and I still stared at the screen until the very end. Somewhere along the way, winning or losing stopped mattering. I was just looking at the scoreboard, wondering how high the number would go.

At that point it wasn’t watching rugby anymore. It was supervising a number as it climbed.

The Players Weren’t Slacking Off

The players weren’t slacking off. You could tell that just by watching.

But before you even get to differences in size or skill, they simply didn’t function as a team. Attack and defense never meshed, and there was no coordination. Against England, they conceded a try in the first minute, then fell hopelessly behind while playing a man down after a red card. For all practical purposes, the match was over right there.

The World Cup is next year. If they go into the tournament at this level of readiness, it’s painfully obvious how that will end.

Play England at Baseball and Japan Wins

Still, I think it’s a bit off to pin this thrashing on the players or the coach alone.

In international sport, a country’s strength tracks, almost cruelly, how popular a sport is at home and how many people actually play it.

I’m not denying that rugby itself is an appealing game. But in Japan today, very few people are actually out there chasing an oval ball.

It’s easier to see if you flip it around. If Japan played England or Scotland in a serious game of baseball, Japan would be so far ahead that the mercy rule would kick in. There’s no doubt about it. Japan has a baseball culture built up over generations, and a deep pool of players.

From their side, Japanese rugby is basically what English baseball is to us.

Seen that way, these blowouts were bound to happen. There’s nothing to do but accept it.

The Only Way Is to Widen the Base

If Japanese rugby seriously wants to stand shoulder to shoulder with the world, there’s a limit to what short-term national team programs or tactical fixes can do.

Kids need to be able to pick rugby as naturally as they pick baseball or soccer. You have to widen the base itself. In the end, that’s the only way.

Until then, we’re going to be living with scores like these for a long time.

That said, I do know the shortest route to beating England.

Get them to make the next match a baseball game. They’ll probably say no.