A Concert Where You Pay ¥10,000 and Never See the Band

A small uproar broke out online over a certain concert.

Someone who went to a concert by a masked band posted angrily: “The ticket cost ¥10,000, about $67, and the band never showed up. They just played videos on a big screen.”

This band has never shown their faces since their debut. Not only that, the members apparently don’t even come to the concert venue. There is a giant screen on stage showing CG animation based on the members’ motion capture and music videos. That, apparently, is the concert.

I can understand why someone who went without any background knowledge would be angry.

They probably assumed the band members would be on stage singing, maybe wearing masks. But in reality, it was not much different from watching a movie in a theater. And it cost ¥10,000.

”It’s Your Fault for Not Doing Your Research”

But longtime fans pushed back against the post all at once.

Every fan knows the band doesn’t show their faces and doesn’t come to the venue. Everyone pays ¥10,000 fully aware of that, to support the band’s activities. In other words: it’s your fault for coming without doing your research.

As logic goes, it makes sense. If fans understand it and are enjoying themselves, it’s not for outsiders to complain.

But this band’s songs are often used in TV dramas and commercials. Plenty of people probably buy tickets on a whim: “That song’s great. Maybe I’ll go see them live.”

Telling those people, “The band doesn’t come. Everybody knows that,” only works for people who are already on the inside.

The Logic of Offerings

Watching this uproar, I was suddenly reminded of trouble involving religion.

For devoted believers, large donations and payments for intangible services are all precious “ofuse,” offerings made out of faith. If the believers are genuinely convinced and happy, it works as a world of its own.

But things change when someone who knows nothing wanders in, drawn by the bright atmosphere at the entrance. Offerings that are normal on the inside look like plain rip-offs from the outside.

With both “oshi-katsu,” the Japanese word for devoting yourself to supporting your favorite idol or artist, and religion, the more passionate people get, the further the common sense on the inside drifts from the common sense on the outside. And the further they drift apart, the more puzzled insiders become: “Why don’t they get it?”

This uproar was a classic clash that happened right on that boundary.

More Generous Than a Hidden Buddha

That said, Japan has an even more advanced world: the “hibutsu,” or hidden Buddha.

Some temples have Buddhist statues that are shown to the public only once every few decades. Even so, visitors pay an admission fee, put their hands together in front of the closed doors, and go home. They never once see what’s inside, yet nobody calls it fraud.

Above that, there is even the “absolute hidden Buddha.” At some temples, not only ordinary visitors but even the head priest has never once seen the statue.

At this point, whether the actual statue exists is no longer the question. Visitors have no choice but to picture their own Buddha in their hearts behind the closed doors and pray.

Looking at it that way, that concert starts to look different.

Not getting to see the band may be terrible for a concert. But since it at least shows you video, it is quite generous as hidden Buddhas go.