A Million Drones Instead of Nukes: Japan's New Defense Idea Was More Radical Than I Expected
Whenever national security comes up in Japan, it’s always a choice between two options.
Should Japan arm itself with nuclear weapons? Or stay non-nuclear to the end?
But the other day, a military commentator laid out a “third option,” and it was pretty shocking.
A million drones.
An Era When Even the U.S. Military Pulls Back
As a premise, the commentator pointed to the Middle East.
Now that saturation attacks, launching huge numbers of cheap drones at once, have become reality, no matter how advanced your air defense system is, you can’t keep up with the number or the cost of interceptor missiles. That’s why, during the war with Iran, the U.S. military apparently pulled its forces back from bases in the Gulf states for a while.
The host countries reportedly weren’t happy about it. Of course not. The military that was supposed to protect them evacuated first.
Militarily, though, it was the right call, the commentator said. If you can’t intercept everything, you pull back for a while and preserve your forces. When you think about it calmly, that makes sense.
The problem is that the same logic applies directly to Japan.
If a full-scale clash with China broke out, U.S. forces in Japan might disappear for a while to avoid the rain of missiles and drones in the opening phase of the war. According to the commentator, that scenario is entirely possible.
As long as the U.S.-Japan alliance exists, America probably wouldn’t abandon Japan. Left alone, all of Asia would end up in China’s hands.
But for the first few weeks, it might be, “Sorry, we’re cheering you on from a safe distance.”
Instead of “No Possessing, No Producing”
So while the U.S. military is away, how does Japan stop an enemy from attacking?
Japan has long held non-nuclear principles, including not possessing and not producing nuclear weapons, and getting nukes right now isn’t realistic, politically or internationally. That’s where an expert came up with the idea of deploying a million drones inside Japan.
During the Cold War, the U.S. and the Soviet Union avoided war through a balance of terror: “If either of us uses nukes, we both get wiped out.” That’s what’s known as mutually assured destruction. The idea is to do the same thing with drones instead of nukes.
Japan doesn’t get nuclear weapons. But if Japan is attacked, it strikes back at the attacker’s cities and infrastructure with a massive number of drones, at a comparable scale.
As a shift in thinking, it’s pretty bold.
The Ultimate Game of Chicken
Of course, it comes with risks.
The other side has nuclear weapons. If Japan dealt a massive blow to Shanghai with drones, a cornered opponent might say, “Then we’ll use nukes.”
In other words, it’s the ultimate game of chicken.
You can’t overdo it. You can’t let them think you’re a pushover either. You have to return exactly as much pain as you received, precisely. It calls for a very delicate balance.
But realistically, I can already picture the Diet, Japan’s parliament, spending months debating “the appropriate scale of a drone counterattack.” By then, the war would be over.
The Biggest Hurdle
The deterrent power of a million drones. It sounds like science fiction, but as a realistic card for a Japan that can’t have nuclear weapons, the day it gets seriously debated may not be far off.
There’s just one thing I’m worried about.
In Japan today, even flying a single drone often requires an application to the transport ministry.
Getting flight permits for a million drones would probably take longer than deploying them.