A War Where You Empty a Whole Can of Bug Spray on Every Mosquito: Watching a Taiwan Invasion Simulation

The other day, I watched a video that used AI to rerun an American think tank’s simulation of a Chinese invasion of Taiwan, with the conditions tweaked a little.

Under every set of conditions, the conclusion was the same: “China’s occupation of Taiwan fails.”

If that’s all you hear, it sounds like a win for the US and Taiwan. But once you look at the details, it’s hard to call it a win at all. It isn’t only China that takes losses. The US also loses several aircraft carriers, and its most advanced air-defense missiles and long-range missiles run out early. Even the winning side ends up battered almost beyond recognition.

Why does the US military, the strongest in the world, take such a beating? The key factor the video pointed to was drones.

The More You Intercept, the Poorer You Get

Today’s air-defense systems are built on the assumption that incoming missiles and aircraft will be shot down with high-performance interceptor missiles.

Then a huge swarm of cheap suicide drones comes flying in.

You might think, “If they’re cheap, they’re basically decoys, so why not just ignore them?” But every one of them carries explosives. Leave them alone and they’ll slam into your ships and radars, so you have no choice but to shoot them down.

The problem is the price. To bring down a drone worth tens of thousands of dollars, you fire an interceptor missile that costs millions.

It’s like emptying an entire can of bug spray every time you kill a single mosquito. And thousands of mosquitoes are coming.

Then why not shoot them down with cheap machine guns, you might think. In fact, warships do carry machine guns meant to shoot down missiles that get close.

But machine guns have a short range. If drones come diving down from above in huge numbers, there’s no way to handle them all. A mosquito coil won’t stop a swarm of mosquitoes.

So in the end, you have to rely on interceptor missiles. Keep that up, and even the best air-defense system runs through its stockpile in no time. The moment the interceptors are gone, the aircraft carriers and Aegis destroyers are completely exposed. That’s when the real missiles come in.

Precision Guidance Has Become Cheap and Easy

Precision-guided weapons, the kind that can destroy a target with pinpoint accuracy, used to be expensive, special-order items.

Advances in technology have made it possible to build them cheaply and in large numbers. The trend in warfare is shifting from “use a few expensive weapons” to “scatter huge numbers of cheap ones.”

The result of all this high tech is that what’s happening in the sky is an old-fashioned, grinding war of attrition.

At that point, eventually, instead of meeting them with expensive missiles, people will start throwing drones at drones. Cheap unmanned aircraft endlessly smashing each other in the sky. What a dull future.

In the End, It Comes Down to Whether People Can Cross the Strait

So once the carriers are sunk and the missiles are gone, how is the fight actually decided?

Taiwan is an island. For China to occupy it, in the end it has to put soldiers on ships, send them across the strait, and land them.

That’s why China failed in the simulation. No matter how many missiles and drones it fires, it can’t fully control the sea and the sky, so it can’t safely move a force of tens of thousands across. If it can’t get rid of American submarines, its transport ships get sunk, the troops never arrive, and the operation falls apart.

No matter how far drones advance, what completes an occupation is, in the end, human beings on ships.

A World Where Cost-Effectiveness Wins

Of course, this is just a simulation under particular conditions. In reality, far more complicated factors come into play, such as electronic warfare, cyberattacks, and the jamming of satellites.

Still, the picture of missiles costing millions of dollars each being eaten alive by swarms of drones costing tens of thousands is very realistic.

It seems war, too, has finally entered the age of value for money.

No matter how many state-of-the-art aircraft carriers you have, you can’t feel safe anymore.

The country that wins the wars of the future will be the one best at buying in bulk at the dollar store.