A Well in Uganda and the Truth About "Mindo," Japan's Idea of Civic Virtue

The other day, I watched a video about water problems in Uganda.

A well in one village broke, so the village chief went from house to house to collect money for the repair. But all the chief got back were answers like, “I haven’t used that well lately,” and “That well was built with international aid, so fixing it is the aid organization’s job.”

In the end, the money was never collected, and the well was left broken.

The video presented this as an example of a country with low “mindo.” Mindo is a Japanese word for the level of civic-mindedness and public manners in a society, and Japanese people often praise themselves for having a high one.

Honestly, that was my first reaction too. In Japan, the neighborhood association would collect the money and get it fixed in no time.

But afterward, something else started to bother me. Have Japanese people really always had such high civic virtue?

When I looked into it, the answer was completely different.

Old Japan Was a “Mad Max” World

There is a vague image that the Japanese have always been a polite people, full of the spirit of helping one another.

But when you look at history, that picture is nowhere to be found.

Not only during the Warring States period of the 15th and 16th centuries, but for hundreds of years before it, the purpose of government was not to serve residents. It was to collect rice taxes and prevent rebellions. The people of a domain were less residents to be protected than simply productive capacity.

When war came, villages were burned, kidnapping was rampant, and human trafficking was not unusual. The strong took, and the weak were taken from.

By today’s standards, it was practically the world of “Mad Max.”

In a society like that, if you said, “Let’s all chip in for everyone’s sake,” no one would go along. Making sure you yourself survived was surely the most rational choice.

In the Edo Period, the Japanese Became a Different Species

Some historians say that the Japanese changed so much between before and after the Edo period (1603–1868) that you could almost call them culturally different peoples.

It sounds like an exaggeration, but once you understand how the Edo system worked, it starts to make sense.

What the Tokugawa shogunate built was not just peace. It was “a society where cooperating pays off.”

First, the feudal lords were made responsible for governing. If a major peasant uprising broke out in their domain, their land could be confiscated. After the Shimabara Rebellion, the lord was stripped of his domain and even beheaded. The age when a lord only had to collect taxes was over.

Human trafficking was banned in principle, and the wars came to an end. De facto slave labor, such as sending children into servitude as collateral for debts, still remained. But at least it was no longer a society where you might suddenly be kidnapped and sold one day.

Then there was the famous “gonin-gumi,” the five-household groups.

Farmers were held jointly responsible and watched over one another. If one person committed a crime, everyone was held accountable, and they helped each other pay the rice tax. Today, it would be harshly criticized as a complete surveillance society.

On top of that, residents’ family registers were managed by Buddhist temples, and the feudal lords were required to live in Edo, today’s Tokyo, at regular intervals. The entire country was built into one giant management system.

Freedom decreased. But in exchange, there were more than 260 years without a major civil war. Businesses could keep running, fields could be farmed again the next year, and promises were kept.

Follow the rules, and you can live in peace. The Japanese experienced that simple fact for generation after generation.

Civic Virtue Is Not DNA. It Is Institutions

That’s why, whenever I hear “The Japanese have high civic virtue,” I tilt my head a little.

Civic virtue is not in a people’s DNA. It is the result of institutions.

If you cooperate, you benefit too. If you follow the rules, you can live safely. Living in that kind of society for hundreds of years is what produced the Japanese people of today.

Flip it around, and without those conditions, things change.

You can’t trust the government. You don’t know if the money you pay will be used properly. Only the people who honestly pay end up losing out.

In a society like that, saying “I don’t use that well, so I won’t pay” is less a sign of low morals than a perfectly sensible form of self-defense.

What Japan’s Civic Virtue Really Is

Donating the well itself is easy. But building a society where people can believe that cooperating pays off takes an enormous amount of time. Even Japan took hundreds of years.

And if you look closely, the substance of Japanese civic virtue is not all that admirable either.

Japanese people strictly follow the garbage-sorting rules not because their hearts are pure. It’s because they’re scared of the nosy neighborhood auntie who stands guard over the garbage collection point.

She is probably the rightful descendant of the five-household groups.

What the well in Uganda really needs may not be aid money, but one of those nosy aunties who stand guard over Japan’s garbage collection points.