At My "Peace-Loving" Alma Mater, the Slaps Kept Coming
He has since passed away, but long ago I heard a rakugo storyteller talk about his experience of the war.
As a child, he was caught in a fierce air raid. The city became a sea of fire, and as people fled in every direction, the boy found a drum filled with water, jumped in, and protected himself from the flames.
The problem is what came next. The drum barely had room for one person. All around him, people were being swallowed by the fire one after another. He said he closed the lid and prayed that no one would notice him.
On stage, too, he was a cynic, with a style that looked at the world from a skeptical angle. Hearing this story, I understood exactly why. He himself said, “Left alone, people can become as evil as you like, and in the end they only think about themselves.”
He closed the story with, “That’s why peace matters.” I have no objection to that. But what stuck with me was not the conclusion. It was the middle. When people are pushed to the edge, one layer of reason peels away, and they become just another animal. The one who closed the lid on that drum was not a bad person. He was an ordinary child.
The Not-So-Peaceful Daily Life of a School Devoted to Peace Education
Every time I recall that story, I think of my own alma mater.
The combined junior and senior high school I attended was extremely enthusiastic about peace education. As I remember it, the school motto was something lofty along the lines of “Reject violence and love peace.”
And the reality? Bullying was rampant, and corporal punishment by teachers was an everyday occurrence. At a school that rejected violence, the ones using the most violence were the teachers.
Apparently, a love of peace was something to be delivered by way of the students’ cheeks.
Back then, the gap between the sign on the wall and the reality made me laugh before it made me angry.
That said, looking back now, I can see the logic: preaching peace to a bunch of hormonal teenage brats is pointless, so you hit them to make them obey.
If Chanting Brought Peace, Nobody Would Struggle
Chinese philosophy has two views of human nature: that people are born good, and that people are born bad. At least in what I have seen, the second explains far more. When the rules and restraints of society come off, people become self-centered surprisingly easily.
The trouble with pacifism is that it refuses to look at this. People are fundamentally good, the thinking goes, so if you teach them how precious peace is, conflict will disappear. Believing that, schools put up slogans, have students write essays, and fold a thousand paper cranes.
If that brought peace, my alma mater should have been the most peaceful place in the world.
Left alone, people will push others down without a second thought, whether to protect themselves or to put themselves on top. So what we need is not beautiful words. We need rules and an environment that keep people from turning back into animals.
Who Understood People Most Honestly
Peace matters. On that, the rakugo storyteller was right.
But peace is not something you get by chanting slogans. The people who know how easily humans can turn bad understand that best.
At the very least, the boy who closed the lid on that drum understood human beings more honestly than the teachers who preached peace while slapping their students.