Before Laughing at India's Caste System, Let's Talk About Japan's Own Class System

When I hear about India’s caste system, I can’t help thinking, “What a backward society.”

But before Japanese people say that, we should take a look at our own feet. Until not so long ago, Japan had a full-fledged class system of its own.

Today, Japan has no legal class status. Apart from the special case of the Imperial Family, everyone is equal under the law. And even the Imperial Family is not granted any special privileges as such.

Even so, I sometimes hear that discrimination based on the old class system still lingers in some areas, such as the Kansai region around Osaka and Kyoto.

What Counted as “Impure” Was Decided by Price

In the Edo period (1603–1868), there was a class division often summarized as “shi-nō-kō-shō”: samurai, farmers, artisans, and merchants.

Apparently, the mainstream view among historians today is that it was closer to a division of occupations than a strict hierarchy. Still, it is certain that the samurai were the ruling class, and that merchants were looked down on under the influence of Confucianism, which despised commerce.

And placed outside that framework, facing harsh discrimination, were people called “eta” and “hinin,” labels that are now considered deeply derogatory.

The work they did included butchering animals, processing leather, and assisting with the capture and execution of criminals. They were forced to take on jobs that were shunned at the time as “impure,” as well as dangerous behind-the-scenes work.

What I find interesting is that handling human waste, which India’s caste system treats as work for the very lowest, was not a target of discrimination in Edo-period Japan.

At the time, human waste was valuable fertilizer called “shimogoe,” or night soil. It was a proper commodity that farmers paid money to buy.

In other words, what decided whether something was dirty was not its smell, but its price. Our human sense of “impurity” turns out to be rather arbitrary.

Merchants and Actors Rose Up, But…

The power balance between classes also shifted over time.

As a long era of peace continued and the economy got moving, the merchants, who held the money, gained real power. Some wealthy merchants became far richer than the lords of small domains, and the lords began bowing to merchants to borrow money. On paper, the merchants ranked lower. In their wallets, they ranked higher.

The entertainment world was the same. Kabuki actors were originally discriminated against and called “kawaramono,” literally “riverbed people,” but when kabuki became wildly popular, they turned into great stars of the common people. Their status stayed low, yet their popularity rivaled that of feudal lords. A strange kind of existence.

While others climbed up through money or popularity, the people labeled “eta” and “hinin” were left behind.

In 1871, the Meiji government’s Emancipation Edict officially abolished class discrimination, and everyone became a commoner.

But even when the law changes, what is inside people’s heads does not change right away. This time, the memory of place, “which community are you from?”, became the marker, and discrimination in marriage and employment stubbornly continued. This is what is known as buraku discrimination, after the word for those communities.

Redevelopment Erases the Boundary Lines

What changed this structure dramatically was Japan’s postwar high economic growth and urbanization.

People moved around constantly, and nobody could keep track of where everyone was from.

I was born in Tokyo, and I have never once been aware of buraku discrimination in my daily life. Probably because it is a city that has kept taking in outsiders ever since the Edo days. In Kyoto, on the other hand, where old history remains strong, that memory seems to have lasted much longer.

But even in Kyoto, redevelopment has transformed the city, and the residents have changed. The boundary lines themselves, “where was it?”, are gradually becoming impossible to tell.

That said, it has not disappeared completely. Even now, there are people who post lists of place names online, and it has ended up in court.

They go out of their way to redraw lines that were fading. How very diligent of them.

The Ones Who Discriminate Never Change

About 150 years have passed since the Emancipation Edict. Society is finally starting to catch up with an equality that existed on paper long ago. It took a century and a half.

And just when I thought this problem was finally fading, friction with foreign workers and immigrants has started to become a new source of conflict.

In every era, humans are remarkably eager about one thing: finding “someone who is different from us.”

After 150 years, the people being discriminated against are finally starting to change. But the people doing the discriminating seem to be much the same as they were in the Edo period.