Do We Think the Words "Education Costs" Justify Anything?

Lately, I often see news stories and documentaries about households struggling with rising prices.

The other day, I was watching a TV program that reviews family budgets, and I couldn’t help talking back to the screen.

The first family had somehow managed to put their child through high school, but they were agonizing over not being able to pay for university.

The financial expert made a perfectly ordinary suggestion: “Let’s have your child take out a student loan.” But the parent flatly refused, saying, “My parents sent me to university. So I want to do the same for my child.”

A noble sentiment. But noble sentiments don’t pay tuition.

The second family was a little better off. Because of rising prices, the cost of their child’s piano lessons was putting a strain on the household budget.

The household budget was already playing out of tune.

No Calculators Allowed in the Sanctuary

I don’t have children. So I can’t truly understand how parents feel.

But looking from the outside, I find it endlessly puzzling. Why do people suddenly stop doing the math the moment the words “education costs” are attached?

People who normally search the supermarket for eggs that are a few cents cheaper will readily accept expenses of thousands or even tens of thousands of dollars the moment someone says, “It’s for the kids.” Education costs are a sanctuary in Japanese households, and apparently calculators are not allowed inside.

Take the piano. If the household budget is tight, it should be one of the first fixed costs to review. Instead, the parents would rather cut their own lunch money. Unless the child is actually headed for a career as a pianist, this is less education than a subscription called extracurricular lessons.

The Destination: A Bottom-Tier University

What’s more, the university the first family’s child wanted to attend seemed to be one of the kind people in Japan call “F-rank,” a bottom-tier school that admits almost anyone who applies.

If the child has something they clearly want to study, that’s a different story. But going to university vaguely because everyone around you does, while the parents tip the household finances over to pay for it, really does not seem worth it.

“Investing” means putting up money in expectation of a return. Putting up money without ever calculating the return is not investing. It is simply a donation.

In the end, I wonder whether a lot of education spending is less about the child’s future and more about buying the reassurance of “I’m doing right by my child as a parent.” Parents are paying monthly lesson fees for their own satisfaction at being able to give their child what everyone else has.

The Student Loan Just Ends Up Coming From a Different Window

The greatest irony is where the parents’ beautiful resolution, “I don’t want my child to go into debt,” finally leads.

To keep their child from taking out a student loan, the parents dip into their savings and stretch themselves to pay the tuition. Naturally, their retirement savings shrink.

Then, 20 years later, who will take care of the parents when they run out of money? That same child.

In other words, instead of borrowing from the Japan Student Services Organization, the country’s main public student loan provider, the child simply borrowed from a financial institution called “Mom and Dad.”

And this loan is repaid with plenty of interest, in the form of financial support and elder care in their parents’ old age.

I’m sure parents don’t want to hear all this from someone without children.

Then again, I don’t even have anyone to collect from, with interest, in my old age.