I Happened to Walk Past Yasukuni Shrine, So I Gave It a Little Thought
I was walking around Tokyo for work when Yasukuni Shrine came into view.
It’s a place I normally only see on the news. Every August it’s on TV without fail, and every year there’s the same uproar over whether the prime minister will visit. That shrine.
Still, what stood in front of me was just a big torii gate. The people making all the noise are mostly outside the shrine.
The Trouble Started with the Class-A War Criminals
Yasukuni Shrine honors the war dead from the final years of the samurai era through World War II. It wasn’t always the diplomatic problem it is today.
The mood changed when the so-called Class-A war criminals were enshrined there.
From the point of view of China and South Korea, ordinary soldiers were people mobilized by the state, and there’s still some room to understand that. But enshrining the top leaders who directed the war alongside them is another matter. In German terms, it looks like the chancellor paying respects at a shrine to Nazi leaders. Of course they’re angry.
Ever since, as August 15, the anniversary of the end of the war, approaches each year, conservatives say “the prime minister should visit” and liberals say “be considerate of our neighbors.” It’s been the same script for decades. At this point it’s practically a summer tradition.
The Government Can’t Say “Take Them Out”
I have a simple question. If the Class-A war criminals are the source of the trouble, couldn’t the government just say, “Please remove them”?
As it turns out, it can’t.
Since the war, Yasukuni Shrine hasn’t been a state facility. It’s a religious corporation, in other words a private shrine. It’s the shrine, not the government, that decides who is enshrined as a deity.
On top of that, Japan’s constitution guarantees freedom of religion and the separation of religion and state. If the government told a religious organization to “take this deity out,” that itself would violate the constitution.
Everyone Becomes a God After Death
What makes it even more complicated is the Japanese view of life and death.
In Japan, there’s a feeling that once you die, what you did in life is washed away, and everyone becomes a god or a Buddha. Between Japanese people, “well, they’ve passed on” is enough to settle it. But overseas, a leader’s responsibility doesn’t disappear just because he died. No matter how much you explain, the two views never meet.
The bereaved families have their own circumstances too. For people who sent family members off to war, the story “your father was a perpetrator in a war of aggression” is hard to accept. It was the story that “he gave his life to protect his country” that let them come to terms with their grief.
But once the war leaders were enshrined alongside them, the place for mourning their families turned into a stage for diplomacy and politics. For the families, it’s collateral damage they never asked for.
The idea of building a new national memorial with no religious character has come up several times, but many people have special feelings for Yasukuni, and it never gets anywhere.
A Shrine Protected by Democracy
Thinking it over as I walked past, this is the part I found most interesting.
After losing the war, Japan gained freedom of religion and the separation of religion and state through a new constitution. It’s a democratic mechanism to keep the state from using religion the way it did before the war.
Thanks to that mechanism, the state can’t lay a finger on a shrine that honors the leaders of the war.
Rules made out of remorse for the prewar era are protecting a shrine that honors the prewar era.
The reason the Yasukuni problem never gets solved isn’t that someone is breaking the rules. It’s that everyone is following the rules properly.