I Oppose Japan Getting Nuclear Submarines Alone. If We Get Them, They Should Come With Nuclear Weapons
A public opinion poll on whether Japan should acquire nuclear-powered submarines has been getting attention. Apparently, half of the respondents said they were against it.
Actually, I am against it too.
But not out of pacifism. My reason is far more blunt.
A nuclear submarine without nuclear weapons costs far too much for what little it adds.
Buying the Safe and Leaving It Empty
The selling point of a nuclear-powered submarine is that it can stay submerged for months. It doesn’t need to refuel, so it can travel long distances without being detected by the enemy.
But if all it carries are conventional missiles, that’s a different story. It costs an enormous amount to build and maintain, and it needs a much larger crew than a conventional submarine. Whether it raises deterrence enough to justify all that is highly questionable.
It’s like buying a vault as sturdy as a bank’s and keeping a single coin purse inside.
A nuclear submarine only really makes sense when it carries nuclear missiles.
If we seriously imagine a day when the United States no longer protects Japan, Japan would have no choice but to have nuclear weapons. And if Japan has nuclear weapons, it needs nuclear submarines that can reliably strike back from under the sea even if the mainland is attacked first.
With that combination in place, even China, which keeps building up its military, would find it very hard to lay a hand on the Japanese mainland. Nuclear submarines and nuclear weapons are a package deal to begin with.
If We Are Going to Debate This, Do It While the American Umbrella Is Still Open
The question is when to start the debate.
I think the sooner, the better.
What would happen if Japan rushed to develop nuclear weapons only after America abandoned it? For the several years until they were finished, Japan would stand completely exposed as “a country that intends to get nuclear weapons.” From China’s point of view, it would be natural to think about striking before they were complete.
This is not just theory. In fact, the United States teamed up with Israel to bomb Iran’s nuclear facilities, and the war is still going on. Preventing Iran from obtaining nuclear weapons is said to be one of the main reasons.
America itself has already shown us what happens to a country before it gets nuclear weapons.
Going out to buy rain gear after you’ve lost your umbrella is too late. If we are going to prepare, the time is now, while America’s umbrella is still open.
”We Might Just Get Nuclear Weapons on Our Own” Works on America
There is one more effect of debating nuclear weapons: it helps keep America from walking away.
What America would hate most is Japan getting its own nuclear weapons. There is no guarantee that a nuclear-armed Japan would keep obediently doing what America says. America surely wants to avoid adding one more nuclear power in Asia that it cannot control.
So if Japan keeps a look on its face that says, “If it comes to that, we can start developing nuclear weapons at any time,” America will find it much harder to casually say, “Maybe we should end the US-Japan alliance.”
As a negotiating tactic, it is close to telling a partner who brings up a breakup, “I can’t promise what I’ll do.” Not very classy, but effective.
A Case for Four Non-Nuclear Principles
Getting only nuclear submarines as things stand now would be expensive and half-baked, and I am against it.
But if we are serious about the future, I think the combination of nuclear weapons and nuclear submarines should be on the table as an option.
And yet in Japan, merely mentioning nuclear weapons gets you attacked from all sides. Since we won’t even debate it, both America and China can do their calculations on the assumption that Japan will do nothing.
Japan’s policy on nuclear weapons has been declared by successive governments as the Three Non-Nuclear Principles. In other words:
“Not possessing, not producing, and not permitting the introduction of nuclear weapons.”
Surely it would be acceptable to at least add “But thinking about it is allowed” and make it four principles.