If White Women Look Cuter to Me, Hollywood Is Probably to Blame
I often watch a YouTube channel where people from other countries hold discussions in fluent Japanese.
The other day, I watched an episode where a Black woman talked about her own experiences: discrimination, dating, and so on. The content was fairly standard for that kind of talk.
But something other than the content caught my attention. A white woman was sitting next to her, and when I looked at the two of them side by side, the white woman just looked cuter to me.
I don’t mean to discriminate. It isn’t a reasoned judgment. It’s simply how it looks to me, at the level of instinct.
That makes me a little uncomfortable. Where does this sense of “cute” come from? Is it something I was born with, or something someone planted in me?
To Japanese People in the 1800s, Western Women Looked Like Demons
When I looked into it a little, I found an interesting story.
In the mid-to-late 1800s, when Japan was just opening up to the West, there are apparently records of Japanese people seeing European women for the first time. They were amazed by how pale their skin was, but they also found them “scary, like oni,” the horned demons of Japanese folklore.
Demons. Far from cute.
By the beauty standards of Japanese people back then, a high nose, deep-set features, and a large build were probably just strange and unsettling.
Then, in about 150 years, the demon became the ideal. I have a pretty good idea who’s responsible. Hollywood.
For a long time, the heroines shining on the screen were mostly white women. Watch that for decades, and “the face of the main character” becomes the standard of beauty. My own sense of it is probably the result of that conditioning too. As an educator, Hollywood is far more effective than school.
Too Far Away Doesn’t Look Beautiful Either
But if you write this off as simply a matter of race, things don’t add up.
Many women from Scandinavia or northern Germany have impressive builds and deeply chiseled faces. They’re white too, but to me they don’t look especially beautiful. Come to think of it, I don’t think there are many Hollywood heroines of that type either. They’re a little off from the Hollywood standard as well.
Personally, the faces I find most beautiful are somewhere right in between Japanese and European.
If a face is too far from the environment I grew up in, I don’t find it beautiful. But if it’s too close, it doesn’t feel fresh. In the end, my sense of beauty seems to be “the Japanese eye” and “the Hollywood eye” added together and divided by two. Not much of a mind of my own.
A Classic Japanese Beauty Would Struggle in Today’s Dating Scene
Japanese standards of beauty themselves have changed again and again over the centuries.
Today, slim figures are celebrated, but the beauties in old Japanese paintings from the Heian period, about a thousand years ago, have round, full faces and narrow eyes. Today they might struggle at a group blind date, a common way for single people in Japan to meet, but back then, that was the height of beauty. I’ve also heard that on some southern islands, there are cultures where the fuller a woman’s figure, the more beautiful she’s considered.
Seen that way, a sense of beauty is less an instinct and more like a fashion created by the times and the media.
If so, a hundred years from now, the world’s standards of beauty should be completely different. Then again, if Hollywood’s influence keeps going like this, they probably won’t change so easily.
Well, either way.
Before I get to see beauty standards change, I, a Japanese guy in his fifties, am not going to be the one chosen under any era’s standards.