Is Everything a Nobel Laureate Says Right? Our Weakness for Authority and "Nobel Disease"

The other day, I was watching YouTube when a video introduced an idea like this:

“This theory was proposed by a Nobel Prize-winning scientist.”

When I heard that, something bothered me.

The Nobel Prize is not awarded to “people who are right about everything.” It recognizes that one particular piece of research made a major contribution to humanity.

And yet, in the video’s thumbnail, it was being treated like a universal guarantee.

The Nobel Prize has certainly become a convenient tool these days.

Even a Genius Is Just an Ordinary Person Outside Their Field

Take Roger Penrose, for example.

He won the Nobel Prize in Physics for his work on black holes, and he is without question one of the leading figures in modern physics.

But he also proposed the “Orch-OR theory,” which claims that human consciousness arises from quantum mechanical phenomena inside the brain.

Physicists are free to take on brain science. New ideas sometimes come from other fields.

The problem is when listeners think, “A Nobel laureate said it, so it must be true.”

In reality, it is hard to say that this theory is widely accepted in brain science or neuroscience.

Being an expert on black holes does not mean you can see inside the brain.

There Are Even More Extreme Examples

James Watson, who co-discovered the double-helix structure of DNA, is another case.

His achievement will be remembered in the history of genetics, but in his later years he repeatedly made poorly grounded remarks about race and intelligence. He was criticized around the world and lost one honorary position after another.

That does not erase his great achievement in discovering the structure of DNA. But it and his later remarks are entirely separate matters.

Even so, we tend to assume, “Someone this brilliant must be right about other things, too.”

It is a textbook example of what psychology calls the halo effect. When someone is surrounded by a halo, it becomes hard to see what is actually inside.

Einstein Really Was in a League of His Own

Of course, there are exceptions.

Einstein was extraordinary even within physics alone.

He received the Nobel Prize for the photoelectric effect, but what the public knows him for is the theory of relativity. On top of that, he made major contributions to the study of Brownian motion and statistical mechanics.

He never did receive a Nobel for relativity, but no one would have been surprised if he had won two or three more. That is how far above everyone else he stood.

Still, whether his political statements and views on life were absolutely correct as well is another matter entirely.

There Is Even a Term Called “Nobel Disease”

In science, there is a term called “Nobel disease.”

It refers to the phenomenon of Nobel laureates later becoming absorbed in extreme ideas or pseudoscience outside their own fields.

For example, Linus Pauling, who won the Nobel Prize twice, enthusiastically argued in his later years that taking massive doses of vitamin C could prevent everything from colds to cancer.

Kary Mullis, who won for inventing PCR, went even further. He denied that HIV causes AIDS, and in his autobiography he even described an experience in which he may have talked with a glowing raccoon.

When you achieve overwhelming success in one field, you probably start to think, “My way of thinking works everywhere.”

Apparently, when you attend the award ceremony in Stockholm, you bring home a strange kind of confidence along with the medal.

Look at the Evidence, Not the Title

I majored in physics as a student.

That is exactly why I think this: the truly excellent researchers are the ones who readily say, “That is not my field.” On the other hand, when someone starts making confident claims outside their field, it is wise to be a little wary.

What matters in science is not who said it. It is what evidence there is, and what attempts to disprove it the idea has survived.

And yet people are convinced the moment they hear “University of Tokyo professor,” the most prestigious academic title in Japan. They trust health advice because it comes from “a doctor.” And when they hear “Nobel laureate,” they even want to ask for life advice.

That is not believing in science. It is just worshipping titles.

Fortunately, I stopped at a master’s degree in physics, so there is no danger of me catching Nobel disease.

I make confident claims about things outside my field on this blog, but that is just a chronic condition of my own.