Is That X Account Really Run by a Muslim?
I was scrolling through YouTube Shorts when a certain video came up.
It was about an account on X (formerly Twitter), claiming to be Muslim, that posted “Japanese food culture has way too much pork. Pork dishes should be regulated,” and was getting flooded with outrage.
Come on. Isn’t this made up?
It’s apparently true that, since Japanese school lunches and similar meals don’t offer halal options, some families have asked to let their kids bring a packed lunch from home instead. In Japan, everyone usually eats the same school-provided lunch, so this takes a special request. I understand that. If there’s something you can’t eat, it’s only natural to ask about it.
But “regulate Japanese pork dishes” is a huge leap. We’ve gone from a conversation about school lunches straight to demanding that tonkatsu (breaded pork cutlet) restaurants shut down.
It Was Probably Written by a Japanese Person
Of course, it’s not impossible that an actual Muslim wrote it. But in that case, they’d be a pretty hardcore extremist, completely different from the ordinary people who live their lives with their faith.
How many people would come all the way to Japan and seriously say, “Pass a law banning pork”? This is the land of tonkotsu ramen, noodles in pork-bone broth. The odds are hopeless.
What seems more likely to me is impersonation.
Someone with an anti-Muslim agenda pretends to be Muslim and writes something extreme. If you pose as a member of the group and say something outrageous, you’re guaranteed to make people hate them, and guaranteed to set off a firestorm. It’s a common tactic online.
Then someone takes a screenshot of the post, turns it into a short video, and spreads it. The person who posted the video isn’t saying anything hateful themselves. They’re just presenting it: “Here’s a post that went up.” That way, it’s unlikely to break any platform rules.
One person starts the fire, another sells photos of it burning. They’ve even got a division of labor going.
On TV, Lies Get You an Apology. Online, They Get You Monetized
I often say that “TV is washed up.”
But if TV or newspapers spread an impersonation like this, it would be a major scandal. At the very least, it’s clear who’s responsible.
The internet is different. Lies and manipulation can be spread endlessly without anyone knowing who wrote them. On TV, if you lie, you end up at a press conference bowing in apology. Online, if you lie, you get monetized.
Of course, being able to speak freely without anyone censoring you is a big advantage of the internet. That freedom and that lack of accountability are probably two sides of the same coin.
In the end, the only way to read information online is to assume you don’t know who wrote it.
By the way, readers have no way of confirming whether the person writing this blog is really an IT engineer in his fifties.