No Flowers at the Airport: Diplomacy's "Bare Minimum," and a Country That Lives Off Tension
I read a newspaper story saying that when Japan’s prime minister went to an international summit in China, there were no flowers waiting at the airport, and she was treated more carelessly than the other leaders.
According to the article, Japan had warned China in advance that it would lodge a formal protest if there were any breach of diplomatic courtesy. In response, China welcomed her at the bare minimum of diplomatic protocol, just enough to give Japan nothing to protest.
No grounds for complaint. But no welcome either.
It’s like a coworker who always answers your “good morning” properly but never once looks you in the eye. It isn’t against any rule. But everyone gets the message.
Diplomacy Has a Line, Too
What’s interesting is that the diplomatic world really does have a line: fall below it, and the other side can protest officially.
And China, knowing exactly where that line was, walked right along it like a tightrope. As petty harassment goes, it was a masterclass.
Relations between Japan and China today are hard to call good. Given public opinion at home, it’s only natural for a Japanese prime minister to take a tough stance toward China. In that case, a cold reception at the airport is to be expected.
As long as China met the minimum, Japan can’t complain, and doesn’t need to. Japan should simply accept that “that’s how they are” and calmly attend the summit. Flowers or no flowers, the agenda is the same.
On the flip side, when Japan welcomes foreign dignitaries, it should receive them courteously, no matter how big or small the country, and whether it likes them or not. A country that openly changes its attitude depending on who’s visiting gets its class questioned for that alone.
That said, treating every country equally is only an ideal.
The Panda Is a Mood Barometer
Chinese diplomacy is very easy to read on this point.
When relations are good, China lends you pandas. When relations sour, the pandas go home and the flowers disappear from the airport. Pandas and flowers are the barometer of China’s mood.
Still, from China’s point of view, the way it treats Japan is probably pretty mild. Compared with America, which is hitting China for real with export controls on semiconductors, leaving out the flowers barely even counts as harassment.
Besides, the one who made China this big in the first place was America itself, which once poured in investment and technology, convinced that “if China’s economy grows rich, it will become a democracy.” Now the very country that raised it is scrambling to beat it down. Busy country, that one.
Who Would Suffer Most from World Peace
Here’s something I can’t say too loudly.
It’s precisely because America and China are at odds that Japan’s geopolitical value has gone up. It’s precisely because there is tension in East Asia that America values Japan, and that Japan has a voice within the Western camp.
What would happen if, tomorrow, America and China made up and the tension in East Asia disappeared?
Japan would become just “an expensive island nation in Asia with a population that keeps shrinking.”
It’s easy to say “may the world be at peace.” But in the reality of international politics, some countries secure their place precisely because there’s a moderate amount of tension. Japan is one of them.
The missing flowers at the airport weren’t a snub. They were proof that Japan is still “a country worth harassing.”
Countries that truly don’t matter get their flowers, right on schedule.