Nobody Has Ever Been Sued for Using an AED. So Why Can't Men Bring Themselves to Help Women?
The other day, I came across a debate about AEDs, the portable defibrillators you see in stations and public buildings.
The argument was that it’s risky for a man to use an AED on a woman who has collapsed.
You have to open the clothing of an unconscious woman, touch her body, and attach the AED pads. Afterward, couldn’t she sue you, saying “he touched my body” or “he saw me naked”? According to one survey, quite a few people said they wouldn’t use an AED on a woman because they were afraid of that kind of trouble.
Honestly, I Get the Feeling
It’s hard to blame people for hesitating.
You try to save a life out of good intentions, and because of that you might end up in court, with your life thrown off course. If you think that way, not many people would be able to step in without a second thought.
On top of that, social media has posts like “Even if I needed an AED, I’d never want a man to touch me” and “If a man saw me naked, I’d definitely sue.” Whether they’re fishing for outrage or saying what they really think, I can’t tell. But every time words like these spread, the mood of “better not to get involved” definitely gets thicker.
If there are plenty of witnesses around, maybe. But helping one-on-one is out of the question. As self-defense, I can understand why more and more men think that way.
It’s Just Like “Is There a Doctor on Board?”
This has the same structure as the call for a doctor on a plane.
When the cabin crew announces, “Is there a doctor on board?”, many doctors reportedly hesitate to come forward. If they treat someone in a cabin with limited equipment and medicine, and the patient dies, they might be sued for malpractice.
The person who raised their hand out of goodwill gets held responsible for the outcome. In that case, it’s safer to sit quietly and eat your in-flight meal.
In Fact, Nobody Has Been Sued
Here’s where there’s a rather interesting fact.
According to lawyers, there has never been a case of someone being sued for using an AED on a woman. Using an AED is a legitimate life-saving act, so it isn’t a crime in the first place.
On the other hand, if a passerby doesn’t help, they bear no legal responsibility either.
In other words, as far as the law is concerned, there’s no problem either way, whether you help or not.
People with a duty of care are a different matter, though. If you’re in a position responsible for safety on the spot, like a schoolteacher or a facility staff member, you can be held responsible for not helping.
And yet, according to one study of high school students who went into cardiac arrest at school, AEDs were used on more than 80% of the boys, but on only a little over 50% of the girls.
If you have that responsibility, you should have no choice but to help. They still hesitate. What they’re afraid of isn’t the law. It’s social media and the eyes of the public.
Something Stronger Than the Law
The United States and Canada have “Good Samaritan laws.” If you help someone in an emergency in good faith, you aren’t held liable unless you were grossly negligent.
Japan’s civil law has a similar provision, but almost nobody knows about it. A law nobody knows about might as well not exist.
Of course, correct knowledge matters too. With an AED, you don’t need to strip off all of someone’s clothes. You can attach the pads by just moving their underwear aside. Once the pads are on, you can cover them back up with their clothes. More and more AEDs now even come with a privacy sheet.
But no matter how well you set up the laws and the equipment, the mood of “I might get sued” is hard to make go away.
The doctor who doesn’t come forward on the plane and the man who freezes at the train station are doing exactly the same thing.
Staring at their phone or their in-flight meal, silently praying, “Somebody else, please go.”