Only 2.6% Want Independence: Okinawa's Shrewdness Goes Back to the Ryukyu Kingdom

Last night I was watching a history program about the Ryukyu Kingdom.

Until the late 19th century, Okinawa was an independent country called the Ryukyu Kingdom. The diplomacy of that era, as the program described it, was fascinating.

Ryukyu took the rare position, even by world standards, of paying allegiance to both China (then ruled by the Qing dynasty) and Japan (through Satsuma, a powerful samurai domain in southern Japan). There were even rules for hiding its ties with Japan whenever envoys came from China. Japanese money and books were kept out of sight. Japanese-style graves were temporarily covered with dirt to hide them.

It’s like hurriedly putting away photos of your lover before your husband gets home.

According to the program, though, the Chinese side apparently had a pretty good idea of what was going on. They still looked the other way. Making it public would have meant a fight with Japan over national pride. They didn’t want to get involved in anything troublesome. That bureaucratic instinct hasn’t changed, then or now.

Why Hasn’t the Independence Movement Taken Off?

As I watched, a question came to mind. Okinawa used to be a separate country, so why doesn’t today’s Okinawa have a bigger independence movement?

I once asked a friend from Okinawa about this. Some people do talk about independence, my friend said, but it has never turned into a big wave. When I asked why, my friend just tilted their head and said, “Hmm, I wonder why.”

I got curious and looked into it.

In a 2016 survey of Okinawa residents by the Ryukyu Shimpo, a local Okinawan newspaper, only 2.6% said Okinawa “should become independent.” But what’s interesting is what comes next. Only 46.1% said “it’s fine to stay one of Japan’s prefectures as it is,” less than half. Most of the rest chose answers like becoming a self-governing state or a federal system. In other words, “stay inside Japan, but with more power.”

So here’s what the people of Okinawa really think:

We’re not leaving. But give us more say.

Was Reversion Really a “Long-Cherished Dream”?

Then was the 1972 reversion, when Okinawa returned to Japan after more than two decades of U.S. rule following World War II, a long-cherished dream that everyone celebrated?

When I looked into this too, it wasn’t that simple. The movement calling for reversion was certainly big. But on the day of reversion, in a park right next to the official ceremony in Naha, a rally was held in the pouring rain to protest “reversion with the bases still attached.”

They wanted to go back to Japan. But nobody had told them the U.S. military bases would stay too. That’s the kind of reversion it was.

Fifty years later, in a 2022 survey, more than 90% of Okinawa residents said reversion was “good” or “somewhat good,” the highest figure ever. While still unhappy about the bases, they have firmly accepted being part of Japan.

An Island Surrounded by Three Great Powers

Here’s my own hypothesis about the “why” that left my friend stumped.

If Okinawa became independent now, things would be far more complicated than in the days of the Ryukyu Kingdom.

Back then, it only had to deal with two countries, China and Japan. Now it’s China, Japan, and America. And Taiwan is right next door. For a small island nation to take on these three great powers alone would be exhausting, any way you look at it.

In that case, it’s better to stay inside the framework of Japan. Japan is a democracy, so Okinawa can openly complain to the government about the base issue. It can show its opposition at the ballot box. As part of an authoritarian country, that wouldn’t be possible.

Stay inside Japan and keep yourself safe. Then say what needs to be said.

Of course, underlying all this is the fact that the people are ethnically close to the rest of Japan, and the history of living as Japanese has grown long, so there’s little appetite for independence at this point anyway.

The Ryukyu Kingdom’s Diplomacy Is Still in Service

Long ago, when Chinese envoys arrived, Ryukyu hurriedly hid every trace of Japan.

Today’s Okinawa isn’t going independent. But when it complains to the government, it shows a little of its Ryukyu face.

It seems the wisdom of surviving between great powers hasn’t rusted one bit, even after hundreds of years.