Proving the Afterlife with Near-Death Experiences? They're Interviewing the Wrong People

Apparently there are doctors and academics trying to prove that “the afterlife is real” by collecting testimony from people who came back from the brink of death.

Let me say this up front: I have no intention of denying near-death experiences themselves.

It’s entirely possible that a dying brain behaves strangely. When your life is in danger, something like the brain’s own painkilling drugs probably comes flooding out. Your whole life flashing before your eyes, or meeting family members who have died, can be explained as hallucinations or replayed memories produced by a brain under extreme stress.

The brain is quite an organ when it comes to elaborate staging.

Every Witness Is Still Alive

But this research has a fatal flaw.

What they’re collecting are, strictly speaking, “near”-death experiences. In other words, every single story comes from someone whose brain was still alive, and who ultimately came back.

There isn’t a single testimony from someone who actually died.

Of course there isn’t. People who have really died don’t come back to give interviews.

Collecting stories only from survivors and concluding “the afterlife exists” is like interviewing only people who turned back halfway through a trip abroad and declaring, “So that’s what the country is like.” They never even got there.

The Only People Who Can Talk to the Truly Dead

It’s simple. If you really want proof, go get the story straight from someone who has died completely.

But right now, the only people who claim they can do that are spirit mediums and itako.

In Japan, around Mount Osore in Aomori, in the far north of the main island, there are itako: elderly women who work as folk spirit mediums. They call up the spirits of the dead and speak on their behalf.

There’s a story about this. Someone asked an itako grandma, “I want to meet Michael Jackson.” Michael came down into her, and the very first thing he said, in the thick local dialect of the region, was:

“Oh, long time no see! How’ve you been?”

Michael, when did you become a relative from rural northern Japan? The itako probably mistook him for the client’s grandfather or something.

So the doctors and academics who are supposed to be doing cutting-edge research turn out to be chasing data that only these grandmas have. Quite an ironic setup.

The Lab Coat Is What Makes It Suspicious

Believing in the afterlife is your own business. As long as it stays within religion and faith, I have no complaints at all.

What I find fishy is putting on the white coat of science, collecting plausible-looking data, and trying to “objectively prove” the afterlife. Collecting only the survivor stories that suit your own hypothesis isn’t science. It’s just religion.

The surest method would be for the researchers themselves to die once and see.

The only problem is, then they couldn’t write the paper.