Sending Migrants Home Was Supposed to Free Up Jobs. Instead, the Country Ran Short of Workers
The other day, I saw a news story about South Africa that made me tilt my head.
South Africa has an extremely high unemployment rate. Partly because of that, resentment toward foreign workers has grown, and the country has been moving to send undocumented foreigners back to their home countries.
Common sense would say that once the foreigners are gone, their jobs open up, and unemployed South Africans can take them.
But according to the news, some workplaces where foreign workers disappeared are now facing labor shortages.
Huge numbers of people are unemployed, and yet there aren’t enough workers.
For a moment, I couldn’t make sense of it.
The Math Is Perfect, But…
“Migrants are stealing our jobs” is a wonderfully easy explanation.
If 100 foreigners are working, send those 100 away, and 100 jobs open up. Put 100 unemployed citizens in their place. As math, it is flawless.
The problem is that people don’t behave like math.
Low pay, hard work, night shifts, a long commute. No matter how unemployed people are, some will naturally say, “I won’t work under those conditions.”
On top of that, when companies rely on cheap labor for a long time, they build their businesses around those wages. They can hire cheaply, so they can sell cheaply. Customers get used to those prices. Before you know it, you have industries that can’t run without foreign workers.
The Energy Drink Economy
Watching this, I thought it resembled energy drinks.
You are tired, but the work isn’t finished. You drink one, and somehow you can keep going. The next day you are tired again, so you drink another.
What you really needed was rest, or less work. But since a drink keeps you moving, nobody changes how they live.
There aren’t enough workers. But companies don’t want to raise wages, and they don’t want to raise prices. Automation costs money. So they bring in people from abroad.
In the short term, it is perfectly rational. But if you suddenly take away only the energy drinks in that state, you don’t go back to a healthy body. You just stop being able to move.
Try Putting Up a Sign at a Convenience Store at 2 a.m.
Japan is not immune to this either.
Late-night convenience stores, izakaya pubs, logistics warehouses, hotels, farms. Nobody in a Japanese city is surprised anymore to see a foreign clerk at a convenience store.
So what would happen if every foreign worker disappeared tomorrow?
In many workplaces, the order is the other way around. It is not that Japanese people stopped working because foreigners came. It is that Japanese workers could not be found at that hourly wage, for those hours, under those conditions, so businesses came to rely on foreigners.
Put up a sign at a convenience store at 2 a.m. saying, “Japanese applicants only. Same hourly wage as before,” and it is hard to imagine a flood of applications.
Raise Wages, But Don’t Raise Prices
If nobody comes, just raise wages. That is absolutely right.
But in the end, the customer pays for that. Beef bowls get more expensive, lunch goes from 1,000 yen to 1,300 yen, or from about $7 to $9, free shipping ends, and the neighborhood convenience store stops staying open 24 hours.
Then the very people who were just saying, “Raise Japanese workers’ wages,” get angry again, this time as consumers: “Everything’s gotten so expensive.”
As workers, we want high wages. As consumers, we want cheap and convenient services. What has quietly filled the gap in that contradiction until now has been cheap foreign labor.
Fewer foreigners. Higher wages for Japanese workers. But don’t raise prices. Keep the stores open 24 hours. And make next-day delivery free, too.
At this point, it is not a policy problem. It is a math problem.
Someone posts “Stop relying on foreigners” on social media, then walks straight to a late-night convenience store and receives a cheap boxed lunch from a foreign clerk.
It seems the one who can’t quit energy drinks is not the country, but us.