The Buddha Didn't Write the Sutras: The Wisdom of Handling Fact and Truth Well

I majored in physics as a student.

So when I see YouTube videos claiming that “quantum mechanics can make your wishes come true” or that “parallel worlds prove the law of attraction is scientific,” I usually close them within a few minutes.

Quantum mechanics is a theory that explains an incredibly tiny world, the world of electrons and photons. Carrying it straight over to human destiny or luck in love is not physics. It is fiction.

In the old days, “God says so” was the ultimate clincher. Now “Science has proven it” sits in that seat.

Isn’t it just that the borrowed name has changed? Thinking about it that way, I started to feel that religion might actually be far more honest.

The Buddha Didn’t Write the Sutras

In fact, many of the Buddhist sutras read in Japan were not written by the Buddha himself.

In today’s historical and textual scholarship, many of the Mahayana Buddhist scriptures widely read in Japan are thought to have been compiled several hundred years after the Buddha’s death.

My family belongs to a Buddhist school devoted to the Lotus Sutra, and as a child, I heard about this at our temple.

“So, are the sutras fake?”

That’s what I thought, even as a child. But the head priest’s explanation was unexpected.

“It was people in later times who put them into writing. But the people who inherited the Buddha’s teachings left them behind in the form of scriptures.”

I thought, “I see.” It doesn’t deny the historians. And yet faith still holds up perfectly well.

I was impressed by how skillfully they distinguish between historical fact and religious truth.

Science and Religion Have Different Jobs to Begin With

When you think about it, it’s obvious.

Science investigates “what happened.” Religion considers “how to live.” They work in completely different departments.

So even when historians say, “This scripture was written in a later era,” religion can calmly respond, “Then learn the spirit that runs through it.”

Pseudoscience, on the other hand, is a religion that calls itself science. It borrows only the words, “quantum mechanics,” “neuroscience,” “the latest research,” and sticks them onto its own claims. If you read the original papers, none of that is written anywhere.

That’s how powerful the brand of science is. Just put on a white lab coat, and people somehow believe you.

The Older the Religion, the Better It Is at Compromise

What’s interesting is that the longer a religion’s history, the better it is at coming to terms with reality.

The Catholic Church once put Galileo on trial, but today it basically accepts both the theory of evolution and the Big Bang theory.

In fact, one of the fathers of the Big Bang theory, Georges Lemaître, was a Catholic priest.

As for the Bible, the mainstream view now reads it as symbol and metaphor rather than as historical fact word for word.

An institution that has lasted for hundreds of years cannot survive by completely ignoring reality. I sense the same shrewdness in Japanese Buddhism.

The People Who Believe It Literally

Of course, that’s not true of every religion.

Some Buddhists believe every word of the sutras was spoken by the Buddha. In Christianity, there is biblical literalism, which treats Genesis as historical fact.

In Islam, too, the position that the Quran is the very word of God and cannot contain any errors is still widely held.

Faith is free. It’s not for outsiders to decide which side is right.

But it’s a different matter when people treat scholarship itself as the enemy and start saying, “Even investigating is a sin.”

What’s more, terrorism and murders have actually happened over satire or criticism of religion. Of course, that is the work of a small number of extremist fundamentalists, not Muslims around the world.

Even so, many people feel, “Writing about Islam is a little scary.” I don’t think that is a very healthy state of affairs.

Religion Can Just Stay Religion

I have no intention of rejecting religion. Humans can’t live on logic alone, and funerals and visits to family graves will probably never disappear from humanity.

So religion should simply speak as religion. It doesn’t need to put on science’s white lab coat.

Conversely, science must not become a religion either. When evidence appears, it readily revises its own theories. That is science’s one redeeming quality, after all.

In the past, people borrowed the authority of God to persuade others. Now they borrow the authority of science. Even after thousands of years, humans probably just borrow whatever name seems strongest in their era.

Still, if quantum mechanics could make wishes come true, physicists should be the ones benefiting the most.

And yet physicists, for the most part, struggle to land a stable academic position, wear worn-out jeans, and look a little broke.