The Host Who Couldn't Say, "I'm Not an Expert, So Please Explain"
A military analyst I always watch appeared on a discussion channel run by a business magazine, so I checked it out.
The discussion was about international affairs and national security, and the interviewer was the magazine’s editor-in-chief. But this editor had almost no background knowledge. Even so, they kept picking fights.
Throughout the conversation, the analyst wore a sour expression but still handled it like a grown-up and went along with the discussion. It was so awkward that I felt uncomfortable just watching.
Three Misfires in a Row
First, Ukraine.
The editor kept repeating things like, “Russia had its reasons for invading. Maybe it couldn’t be helped,” and “Can’t Ukraine compromise and settle this through negotiations?”
Wanting peace is a perfectly valid position. But since the editor was saying this with almost no knowledge of how things had unfolded, the discussion didn’t move forward a single step.
Next, America.
The editor declared, almost as a settled fact, “America is going to pull back from the world and move toward isolationism, right?” The analyst smiled wryly and corrected them: “America has never said anything of the kind.” It was, the analyst explained, what is called rebalancing: leaving support for Ukraine to Europe and concentrating military power toward China.
In casual chatter at a bar, “Looks like America’s pulling out of the world too” would be fine. But when the host of a national security discussion program says it, that’s a bit painful.
The crowning moment was cyberattacks.
“Even if we get hit by cyberattacks from Russia or North Korea, as long as we don’t strike back, it won’t become a war, right?”
It’s the logic that if you get punched but don’t punch back, it isn’t a fight. But once you’re being punched, the fight has already started.
Apparently, this host is politically on the left, absolutely opposed to war, and believes everything can be solved through dialogue.
And with that, they are the editor-in-chief of a business magazine. Wouldn’t this person be better suited to being a religious leader?
The Expert Who Plays Dumb and the Amateur Who Plays Expert
The host of the show I usually watch also sometimes takes the stance of “I’m not an expert, so please explain.”
But that is a technique for asking questions on behalf of viewers and drawing out the expert’s real views. The host knows the subject and deliberately plays dumb. That’s what makes it interesting.
This editor was the opposite.
Confidence that “I’m asking sharp questions” seeped out of every word. And on top of that, they went after the expert while getting basic facts wrong.
An expert who plays dumb is fun to watch. An amateur who pretends to know is just painful to watch.
The Comment Section Was Unanimous
After I finished watching, the YouTube comment section was open, so I took a look.
Sure enough, everyone seemed to be thinking the same thing.
The comments were lined up one after another: “Please replace this host,” “Is a magazine with an editor like this going to be okay?” There were also many expressions of sympathy for the analyst.
I seriously thought about posting a comment myself. That’s how bad it was.
But I held back like a grown-up. I followed the analyst’s example.
Instead, I wrote an entire blog post about it. No matter how you look at it, that’s far more vindictive than a one-line comment.