The Land Law I Memorized for a History Test Actually Broke Japan
I was watching a quiz show on TV when a term I hadn’t heard in years came up: the Law Allowing Permanent Ownership of Newly Cultivated Land, known in Japanese as “Konden Einen Shizai Hō.”
The year 743. It was one of those terms I had desperately memorized in high school Japanese history class without really understanding what it meant.
To me back then, it was just another test term: a law saying that “rice fields you clear and cultivate yourself can be yours forever.”
But thinking about it again as an adult, I realized it was an outrageous law. It turned the shape of Japan upside down from the roots.
”Three Generations” Isn’t Enough to Motivate Anyone
Before this law, rice fields in Japan in principle belonged to the state. The state lent fields to the people and collected taxes from them.
In today’s terms, it was close to China, where all land belongs to the state.
But the population grew, and there weren’t enough rice fields. So the state first issued a law saying, “Newly cultivated fields may be privately owned for three generations.”
Who would seriously farm land they knew would be confiscated three generations later? Sure enough, it didn’t work very well.
So twenty years later came the Law Allowing Permanent Ownership of Newly Cultivated Land.
“Forget three generations. It can be yours forever.”
That was the moment the state gave in to human motivation.
The Exception Starts Eating the Main System
The ones whose eyes lit up at “Clear the land, and it’s yours forever” were the aristocrats and the great temples.
They poured money and manpower into expanding their land one plot after another. This was the beginning of the shōen, the private estates that would come to dominate Japan.
At first, the rule was that even private land had to pay taxes to the state. But the aristocrats used every bit of their political power to win one privilege after another: “This land is exempt from taxes.” “State officials are not allowed to enter.”
The very people who ran the state were cutting their own land off from the state.
Naturally, the state grew weaker. The aristocrats at the center of politics now cared only about their own estates, not the country as a whole.
By the later part of the Heian period, roughly the 11th and 12th centuries, even meetings at the imperial court had apparently become a formality: rituals repeated over and over, with the same agenda and the same conclusion every time.
You might think, “Then why bother holding them?” But plenty of Japanese companies still have meetings just like that. More than 1,000 years later, we haven’t made much progress.
The People Covered in Mud Became Samurai
While the aristocrats were busy with their rituals in Kyoto, who was actually managing and protecting the estates out in the provinces?
Lower-ranking military nobles and local strongmen who had cleared wild land with their own hands. The people who got covered in mud working the land, then took up arms to protect it, eventually became the samurai.
As these on-the-ground powerholders gained strength, the rice taxes stopped reaching Kyoto. Having lost their wallet, which was land, the aristocrats declined, and the age belonged to the samurai.
But surely the state’s original public land was still there? You might think so. But with no one from the capital actually on the ground, local powerholders treated that land as their own too, and over time it simply disappeared.
In other words, an exception the state created “to motivate people” spent several hundred years dissolving the very system of the state itself.
Why Didn’t the Samurai Wipe Out the Aristocrats?
From there, the age of the samurai lasted nearly 700 years. But there is something strange about it.
The samurai, who had seized real power by force, did not slaughter the aristocrats in Kyoto, and they left the imperial family in place.
The samurai gained real power in the form of land and military strength, but they kept relying on the imperial court for the authority that gave their rule its official stamp of approval. The aristocrats, who were no longer a political threat, were kept alive as the keepers of culture and ceremony.
No real power, but not thrown out either. They keep their impressive titles and appear only for important ceremonies.
This may be the real reason Japanese companies still have “senior advisers” and “honorary executives” today.