The Secondhand Internet: Why Do People Talk Like Eyewitnesses to Things That Never Happened?
The moment a juicy story starts going around, everyone online suddenly talks as if they were there.
There are stories that get recycled again and again, at drinking parties, on social media, and on blogs.
“Apparently in America, a burglar fell through a skylight, sued the homeowner, and won.”
“There was this woman who put her wet cat in the microwave to dry it, and it died. She sued the manufacturer because ‘the manual didn’t say not to,’ and got a fortune.”
People tell these with the face of someone who was sitting in the courtroom gallery taking notes. Then they spin them into grand critiques of civilization: “America’s lawsuit culture is insane,” “Common sense has disappeared from the world.”
There’s just one problem.
Neither of these things actually happened.
The Original Story Was a Lot Duller
Both are classic urban legends, made-up stories spread through things like chain emails in the early 2000s.
There is something that looks like the source. In 1982, a young man climbed onto the roof of a California high school to steal a floodlight, stepped through a skylight that had been painted the same color as the roof, fell, and later reached a settlement with the school district.
But the other party was a school, not a family home. And he didn’t win a verdict. It was a settlement.
As for the microwaved cat, there isn’t a single record of a manufacturer losing in court. In reality, if you put a cat in a microwave, you don’t get damages. You just get arrested for animal cruelty.
Stories That Confirm Our Biases Sell Well
The reason stories like these survive so stubbornly is that they’re entertaining, easy to understand, and confirm what everyone already wanted to believe.
Americans sue too much. People these days have no common sense. If that’s what you already think, these stories make perfect evidence.
On top of that, almost nobody starts with “I don’t know if this is true, but…” when they pass a story on. They trim the fuzzy parts, polish the punchline, and present a mere rumor as “established fact.” And while they’re at it, they show off how sharp they are for having spotted what’s wrong with the world.
In an age when checking the original source takes less than ten seconds, everyone still loves playing telephone. Someone repeats what someone else heard, then someone else repeats that, and before you know it, a complete fabrication has become “common knowledge.”
This Blog Is Secondhand Too
Of course, I’m aware of the irony here.
This blog isn’t based on facts I dug up by going to a law library. I just asked an AI and wrote it based on the answers.
In other words, I’m also standing on a pile of secondhand information, complaining that “nobody checks their sources anymore.”
And you, having read this, will probably tell someone tomorrow:
“You know that story about the burglar who fell through a skylight and won his lawsuit? Apparently it’s fake.”
Your source: some random middle-aged guy’s blog you read online.