The Small Trap of "It's on NHK, So It Must Be True": You Can Shape an Impression Without Lying
Japan has a public broadcaster called NHK.
If I were explaining it to someone overseas, I’d say its position is similar to the BBC in Britain. Unlike commercial TV stations, it does not run regular commercial advertising and is funded mainly by license fees. By law, it is also required to be politically impartial and to present multiple perspectives on issues where opinions are divided.
Because of that, many people in Japan feel that NHK is “at least more solid than commercial TV,” and that “if NHK says it, it’s probably quite reliable.”
I’m one of them.
But this trust sometimes becomes a small trap.
Because “not lying” and “telling all the facts” are two completely different things.
What I Noticed While Watching “Toyotomi Brothers!”
Take NHK’s year-long historical drama “Toyotomi Brothers!”
It is a historical drama whose main character is Toyotomi Hidenaga, the younger brother of Toyotomi Hideyoshi, the man who ended Japan’s Warring States period and unified the country.
Hidenaga is known as the man who supported his older brother Hideyoshi, and NHK history programs connected to the drama present favorable aspects of his character and the way he governed his territory.
There’s nothing strange about that.
He’s the main character of a drama they’ll be broadcasting for an entire year. If the related programs kept saying,
“By the way, this man also had some unpleasant sides to him,”
it wouldn’t be much of a promotion.
But when I watched a history program on a commercial channel, a historian casually talked about a different side of Hidenaga.
Apparently he was quite stingy, and in his territory there were harsh money disputes with merchants and others.
That made me think,
“Oh, so there’s that side to the story too.”
NHK wasn’t lying.
And it’s not as if only the commercial station knew the truth.
They simply chose to cover different parts.
You Can Shape an Impression Without Lying
I think this is a pretty important point when it comes to watching the media.
Say there are ten facts, and you present only the five that are convenient.
If all five you present are true, there is no lie in the program.
But for viewers who don’t know the other five, a very different picture of the person takes shape.
In other words, you can change an impression just by choosing facts, without fabricating any.
And in NHK’s case, there is the viewers’ trust: “It’s a public broadcaster, so it must be fair.”
That makes it even more powerful.
This is not a story about NHK being malicious. It’s impossible to convey everything in limited airtime to begin with, and every media outlet chooses what to cover and what to leave out.
The problem is when viewers unconsciously assume that “what wasn’t reported doesn’t exist.”
And NHK Ghost Stories Are Strangely Scary
There is one genre where this trust in NHK works in a completely different direction.
Ghost stories.
I once watched an NHK program that reenacted ghost stories based on real people’s experiences.
It was strangely scary.
On a commercial station’s occult show, they play obviously scary music, darken the screen, and add dramatic touches like:
“What he saw at that moment was…!”
And from the start, you watch in “enjoying a TV show” mode.
But NHK is different.
They interview the people who say they had these experiences and calmly reenact them based on their testimony.
There’s very little hype.
That’s exactly what makes it scary.
”It Was on NHK” Becomes Evidence on Its Own
Of course, just because NHK broadcast a ghost story doesn’t mean it has scientifically certified that ghosts exist.
What the program confirmed probably only goes as far as:
“This person says they had this kind of experience.”
But my brain, as a viewer, goes one step further on its own.
“NHK interviewed them.”
↓
“So it must have been a proper interview.”
↓
“There really is someone who had this experience.”
↓
”…So maybe there really was something there?”
If you think about it calmly, that last arrow doesn’t follow logically.
But the NHK brand fills that gap all by itself.
The public broadcaster’s reputation, which normally increases credibility, becomes a device that amplifies fear when it comes to ghost stories.
With commercial TV, you can shrug it off: “They’re hyping it up again.” But when NHK does it calmly with a straight face, it’s strangely scary.
NHK’s credibility works better than the ghost.
”What They Said” Isn’t Enough
It’s actually not enough to worry only about whether the media is deliberately lying.
What did they choose to cover?
What, on the other hand, did they leave out?
In what order did they show it?
Who did they talk to?
Those things alone can change the impression you get quite a lot.
And the more you trust a media outlet, the less you question its editing.
This is not to say NHK can’t be trusted.
It’s the opposite.
Because it’s NHK, I end up trusting it. That’s exactly why I should be a little careful about the parts my own mind fills in.
That said, maybe I can forget all this when watching ghost stories.
If I calmly analyzed them as “just personal accounts,” it would be a waste of the credibility NHK has spent decades building up as a public broadcaster.
I’m paying the license fee, so I might as well let them scare me with that credibility included.