The TV Network Scolding Big Companies for Misconduct: Has It Ever Looked Inside Its Own Meeting Rooms?

The other day, a TV program ran a special on “the string of misconduct scandals at big companies.” Why do major companies that represent Japan step over the line? The commentators were grilling them hard.

The longer I watched, the more something didn’t sit right with me.

The “Pressure” of a Charismatic Founder

The first case they covered was the accounting misconduct at Nidec, formerly known as Nihon Densan. It’s the company of Shigenobu Nagamori, who built it into a global motor manufacturer in a single generation.

Not long ago, TV was eagerly praising him as “a self-made legend who represents Japan.” Then, late in his career, he suddenly ended up on the side being bashed.

According to the report by an independent investigation committee, no evidence was found that Nagamori directly ordered the misconduct. But he was said to have tolerated some of it, and the report pointed to excessive pressure to hit operating profit targets as part of the background.

Well, unreasonable demands come with the territory at a fast-growing company. The executives under that pressure were presumably getting a position and a salary to match, and probably accepted a certain amount of harshness as part of the job.

Even so, fiddling with the numbers is out of bounds. The moment “don’t make the founder angry” ranks above “obey the law,” a company starts going wrong.

Lowballing Earthquakes in a Nuclear Plant Review

The other case was Chubu Electric Power, which improperly manipulated data related to earthquake assumptions during the safety review for restarting its Hamaoka nuclear power plant.

Fudging how hard the ground could shake, in a nuclear safety review. It sounds like a joke, but it really happened. The president and the chairman have resigned.

According to the investigation report, one of the causes of the misconduct was that management scolded the department in charge for delays in the review. On top of that, inside the company there was apparently its own “homegrown theory of justification,” along the lines of “in the end, there’s no problem with safety” and “we have to restart as soon as possible.”

A homegrown theory of justification. What a phrase. Inside a company, a perfectly respectable-sounding logic can carry the day.

The two cases follow a very similar pattern. There’s intense pressure from the top, rules that only make sense inside the company take root, and before anyone notices, they’ve strayed from society’s rules. To the people inside, it isn’t misconduct. It’s “the right decision to protect the company.”

So, Is the TV Network Doing Okay?

The commentators on the program cut into the companies hard, saying things like “there’s a lack of compliance awareness” and “the culture is far too closed off.”

Watching that, here’s what I thought.

Wait, doesn’t this TV network get bashed itself every so often?

Intense pressure to deliver one number: ratings. Strict hierarchies on the production floor. Industry common sense that’s a bit out of step with the rest of the world. Staged scenes, conveniently edited clips, biased reporting. Every time a problem comes up, it’s mostly the same pattern.

The TV industry surely has one too: a homegrown theory of justification along the lines of “it can’t be helped if we want to get the message across clearly to viewers” and “every network does it.”

Exposing corporate misconduct is an important job for the media. But if you’re going to scold other companies for their corporate culture, you might want to take a peek inside your own meeting rooms first.

At the end of the program, a commentator wrapped up with, “What matters is creating an organization where people can speak up freely.”

I’m looking forward to the day a TV network covers its own scandals with the same passion.