The Whole World Is Collapsing, Yet Somehow Japan Never Does: The Thumbnail Theater of an "Economics Comedian"

I open YouTube, and there it is again: that man’s thumbnail.

“France Collapses.” “Sweden Collapses.” “China Is Collapsing!” “Germany Is Collapsing!” “Farmers Are About to Collapse!”

It’s the familiar Collapse Series from a self-proclaimed economic commentator. On his channel, some country collapses every single week. It’s a wonder the Earth is still spinning.

I don’t watch the videos. The thumbnail alone tells me they aren’t worth watching. He cherry-picks data, blows a narrow problem out of proportion, and keeps milking the same material over and over. If anything is collapsing, it’s mostly his supply of material.

Now Even Chiba Has Collapsed

The crowning touch was a thumbnail I spotted recently: “Chiba Is Collapsing.”

Chiba?

After countries, now we’re down to prefectures. (Chiba is the prefecture right next to Tokyo.) Sure, it did suffer flood damage recently. But calling that a collapse is just lazy. When he starts turning disasters into fuel for fear-mongering, I’m almost impressed at how far he’s run out of ideas.

At this pace, by next year we’ll be getting “Third Street in Some Small Town Collapses.”

After the Collapse, Japan’s Great Comeback

And collapse isn’t his only act. On the backswing, he announces, “Japan is about to make a great comeback!”

He even comes out with “Back in the Meiji era, when Japan began modernizing, its GDP was bigger than America’s,” a claim that would make a history textbook cry. Japan at the time was an agricultural country that had only just started to modernize. Putting it side by side with America is already the opening joke of a comedy routine.

Either he drags other countries down and stokes anxiety, or he makes viewers feel good with “Japan is amazing.” Those are the only two items on the menu. This isn’t economic analysis. It’s a massage parlor that takes turns kneading the viewers’ emotions.

Calling him a commentator is an insult to commentators. He keeps pulling in the crowd with the same surefire bits, so the right name for him is “economics comedian.”

Somehow, Only Japan Never Collapses

There is, however, one thing I find curious.

For all the countries he’s collapsed around the world, “Japan Collapses” never shows up.

A falling birth rate and aging population, a shrinking population, ballooning debt, wages that won’t go up. By any normal measure, the country best suited to the Collapse Series is Japan. It’s a treasure trove of material.

And yet Japan is always cast on the “great comeback” side.

The reason is simple. “Japan Collapses” doesn’t make Japanese viewers feel good. It doesn’t get views.

My guess is that on the day Japan actually collapses, his thumbnail will read:

“Japan: Signs of a Great Comeback!”