Three Lives Taken, Twenty Years in Prison: Why Japan's Law Has Still Made Progress

In a case where a drunk truck driver swerved into the oncoming lane and killed three people in a car, the appeals court also handed down a 20-year prison sentence.

The defense had argued that this wasn’t dangerous driving but only negligent driving, which carries a lighter sentence. In short: “It wasn’t on purpose.”

It’s true that the driver probably didn’t get behind the wheel intending to kill anyone. Even so, looking back at the history of Japanese law, this 20-year sentence marks a major change.

It Used to Be a Five-Year World

In the past in Japan, no matter how recklessly you drove or how many people you killed, you were basically tried for negligence causing death in the course of your work, the same charge used for ordinary accidents. Drunk or not, the maximum was five years in prison.

Drink, get behind the wheel, kill someone, and get five years. When you think about it calmly, that’s remarkably generous.

In response to bereaved families and public opinion saying “the sentences are far too light” and “reckless driving should be judged in a category of its own,” a new crime was created: dangerous driving causing death or injury. It has since moved into a dedicated law on driving offenses, and when someone is killed, the maximum is now 20 years in prison.

This sentence was the full maximum. You could say the law has finally caught up with reality.

The Defendant’s Thought: “Why Twenty Years?”

But if I imagine what’s going on inside the defendant’s head, I suspect there might be a feeling like this:

“I didn’t kill them because I wanted to. I just happened to drink, and just happened to have an accident. So why twenty years?”

Human beings are selfish creatures. To be honest, if I were in the defendant’s position, I would absolutely think that.

But that argument means nothing at all to the families of the victims. Through no fault of their own, one day their loved ones were suddenly taken from them. Whether there was intent to kill doesn’t matter. It’s only natural for them to feel that even twenty years is too short.

For the defendant, it was “one unlucky day.” For the families, it’s the rest of their lives. No number of years in prison will close that gap.

Why I Don’t Drink and Drive

The attitude of “a little won’t hurt” or “it’s fine as long as I don’t cause an accident” is still fairly common out there.

I’ve been writing as if I’m above all this, but honestly, I’m the type of person who could carelessly think “just a little” too.

Luckily, though, I hate driving. And I quit drinking after it wrecked my health.

The reason I don’t drink and drive isn’t some admirable sense of ethics. It’s simply that I have neither alcohol nor a car.

A wrecked liver turns out to be far more reliable than human ethics.