What China Plans to Put on the Senkaku Islands Apparently Isn't Soldiers. It's Drones.

I recently heard an expert on China talk, and it gave me a bit of a chill.

Everyone is worried about a war over Taiwan. But the place in real danger right now, the expert said, may actually be the Senkaku Islands.

The Senkakus are a group of small, uninhabited islands in the East China Sea, between Okinawa and Taiwan. Japan controls them, but China also claims them. They have been a flashpoint for a long time.

So why here, and why now? What the expert described was a cold calculation on China’s side, and a rather nasty new way of taking territory.

A Grand Exit for Xi Jinping

The first reason is what suits Xi Jinping.

As he puts the finishing touches on his time in power, he wants a big achievement that will go down in history. The biggest prize would be unifying Taiwan. But going after Taiwan means a head-on clash with the US military. That risk is simply too high, even for him.

That’s where the Senkakus come in, as an achievement of a more manageable size.

Who Would Die for an Uninhabited Island?

The second reason is the ambiguity of the US-Japan security alliance.

The United States has said again and again that the alliance covers the Senkakus. But would it really risk American soldiers’ lives to fight China in earnest over a few tiny, disputed, uninhabited islands? It wouldn’t be strange if China has concluded that the US “probably won’t show up.”

Against Japan’s Self-Defense Forces alone, China could win through sheer numbers. And apparently there is another calculation too: that the Japanese government would never be able to decide to let its own troops die for an uninhabited island.

I hate to admit it, but that’s a pretty sharp read.

Drones Instead of Soldiers

The worst part is how they would take the islands.

If China landed soldiers, any clash would produce deaths. That would become an international incident, and it would stir up trouble at home in China as well.

So the idea being considered is to send only drones and robots to the islands.

Put unmanned machines on the islands and declare, “This is Chinese territory.” Japan’s forces remove them. China puts them back. They get removed again. China puts them back again.

Since nobody dies, it’s hard to treat any of this as grounds for war. The plan is to keep up the cat-and-mouse game until Japan is worn out, and then quietly turn the situation into an accomplished fact.

At this point it’s less an invasion than a game of whack-a-mole. Except it’s the side doing the whacking that slowly gets exhausted.

The Philippines Lost a Reef to a Typhoon

This isn’t just armchair theory. China has actually done something similar at Scarborough Shoal, which it was disputing with the Philippines.

During a standoff there, the two sides agreed that since a typhoon was coming, both would pull back for the time being. The Philippines withdrew as promised. China didn’t. It simply stayed put and took control of the shoal.

In international affairs, actual control carries enormous weight. If one country holds a place for decades, the world gradually starts treating it as that country’s territory. Look at the Northern Territories, the islands north of Hokkaido that Russia has held since the end of World War II. No matter how often Japan says they are “inherently Japanese territory,” getting them back is realistically impossible.

According to the expert, when China took Scarborough Shoal, Chinese TV ran celebratory specials for three straight days. If China “recovered” the Senkakus, the whole country would be in a festival mood. Xi Jinping would become a historic hero.

A Lesson Worth the Price of One Uninhabited Island

Having written all this, I’ll admit something: personally, I think it might be fine if it happened.

Postwar Japan has treated pacifism like a religion. If you keep saying “peace,” peace will come. If you talk about weapons, you bring war closer. People here have genuinely believed that.

Things have gotten a lot more sensible lately. Even so, merely debating whether Japan should have nuclear weapons is still taboo, and the country still clings to a constitution that renounces war.

It would do Japan good to learn, firsthand and at least once, that the world runs on force. Chanting prayers for peace won’t make the drones leave the island.

If the tuition for that lesson is one uninhabited island, that’s a bargain.

Of course, I can only say that because I don’t live on the Senkakus.

Then again, nobody does.