What's Scarier Than More Foreigners Is Japanese People Getting Used to Looking Down on Them

These days, I really do see foreign workers everywhere. At convenience store registers, in restaurants, cleaning hotels, on construction sites, in logistics. I don’t even think “Oh, a foreigner” anymore.

Yet according to the government’s explanation, Japan does not have an immigration policy.

If you don’t call them immigrants, they aren’t immigrants. That’s a pretty bold line of reasoning.

Different Names, Same Reality

The Technical Intern Training Program, the Specified Skilled Worker visa, part-time jobs for international students. The names of the programs and their official purposes are all different, but from the ground, they are doing one thing: having people from abroad take on work that Japanese people alone can no longer keep running.

With a shrinking and aging population, there aren’t enough workers, so that in itself is a natural development.

What’s strange is that, despite relying on these people this much, we keep avoiding the question: “So how are we going to live together with them?” We bring them in because we need them. We have them work. But they’re not immigrants. So nobody talks about what comes next.

It’s how you’d treat a convenient lover: happy to have them around, but never willing to talk about the future.

What’s Really Scary Is the Change on “Our Side”

Whenever the topic of foreigners comes up online, it quickly turns into a conversation about crime. “Crime will go up.” “They don’t follow the rules.” “Kick out the people who overstay their visas.”

That’s easy to understand, and the answer is simple. If someone breaks the law, deal with it through the law. Same as with Japanese people.

What has stuck with me far more is something a conservative commentator once said.

When large numbers of foreigners come in, the really scary thing is not Japanese people becoming victims, but Japanese people becoming the ones who discriminate.

I agree with that.

We accept foreigners as “people who will work cheaply,” hand them the jobs Japanese people don’t want to do, and even when their working conditions are bad, think, “They should be grateful just to be able to work in Japan.” Whenever a problem arises, we lump them all together: “That’s foreigners for you.”

Keep doing that, and people start building convenient justifications. “They have bad manners.” “Their culture is on a different level.” “They’re lucky to be allowed here, so they shouldn’t complain.” If you think that way, your conscience doesn’t hurt even when you work them hard for little pay.

Before you know it, foreigners have become “people beneath us.”

Criminals can be arrested. But there’s no way to put handcuffs on discrimination that has soaked into a society.

”They’re Not Immigrants, So We’re Fine” Doesn’t Work

Japan studies the immigration problems of Europe and America closely: immigrant neighborhoods, social division, rising crime, the rise of anti-immigration parties. So the thinking goes that Japan won’t repeat the same mistakes.

But bringing in large numbers of foreigners in practice, while keeping up the official line that “this is not an immigration policy,” is far more precarious.

To the government, they are temporary workers. To companies, they fill labor shortages. To the neighbors, they are the foreigners next door. To the people themselves, it is the place where they have lived for years. If the numbers keep growing while everyone sees the situation differently, something is bound to start grinding somewhere.

If We Bring People In, Let’s Do It Properly

I’m not saying we should accept people without limit. Who, how many, and under what conditions? Can they bring their families? How much Japanese should we require? What about social security? The government should decide those things clearly.

But once those decisions are made, the people we accept should be treated as fellow human beings. That should go without saying.

Whenever people talk about the “foreigner problem,” it’s always about what foreigners will do to Japan. But it’s about time we also worried about what Japanese people will start doing once they’ve let foreigners in.

Bring in as many as you want as cheap labor, insist “they’re not immigrants,” and when something goes wrong, blame the foreigners.

For the country of “omotenashi,” Japan’s famous spirit of wholehearted hospitality, that’s pretty sloppy customer service.