Whoever Built the Pyramids, It Just Couldn't Be the Indigenous People

I was watching a YouTube video about Scandinavians who settled in Canada.

Apparently, the Norse of the old days, the so-called Vikings, crossed the sea all the way to North America.

In Japan, some people may know the details from a manga called “Vinland Saga.”

They expanded their settlements to Iceland and then Greenland, and around the year 1000, they settled on the island of Newfoundland in Canada. Ruins have been found there too, so it has been properly proven archaeologically.

But after that, they simply disappeared from Canada. Was it too cold? Did things go badly with the Indigenous people? Or was it just not worth it? If they had gone a little farther south, history might have changed.

In the end, all the Vikings left behind in North America were the remains of a few huts.

A Shocking New Theory in a Children’s Book

Thinking about this reminded me of a book I read at the library as a child.

It was a children’s book introducing ancient ruins around the world. On a page about a civilization, I believe it was the Inca or the Aztecs or one of those, an outrageous theory was presented with total confidence.

Ancient Romans crossed the sea via Scandinavia and built an advanced civilization in South America.

Romans. Via Scandinavia. To South America.

The route alone is quite a stretch. Today it would sit squarely on the occult shelf, but back then, since it was written in a children’s book, I simply read it and thought, “Huh, interesting.”

I’m not sure it was appropriate for a public library to carry that in the children’s section, but it was also an era when the manga corner had erotic manga on the shelves (supposedly based on literature, but still…).

It was a very easygoing time. Or, to put it another way, a sloppy one.

Anyone but the Indigenous People Would Do

Thinking about this theory again now, I realize what lies at its root is not romance.

In short, it is the assumption that “the local Indigenous people could never have built such huge pyramids and stone buildings.”

People found ruins beyond their understanding. But they didn’t want to admit they were the work of Indigenous people. So they brought up the already-known story that “the Norse went to North America” and created a very convenient narrative: “Actually, before Columbus, talented Europeans crossed the sea and built civilizations for them.”

The real Vikings built huts and went home. But the imaginary Romans even built pyramids. The fakes were far harder workers than the real thing.

And this kind of story is not a one-off. The huge ancient earthen mounds of North America were long attributed not to Indigenous people but to some mysterious race from somewhere else. The stone ruins of Great Zimbabwe in Africa were also attributed for a long time to the ancient Phoenicians or some such people.

Apparently, as long as the builders weren’t Indigenous, anyone would do.

Next Up: Aliens

Of course, if you put a theory like this in a children’s book today, it would be a big problem. At least on the surface, racial equality and respect for other cultures have become common sense.

Or so I thought, until I noticed that TV and YouTube are still happily producing programs claiming that “the pyramids were built by ancient aliens.”

Discrimination hasn’t disappeared. The ones stealing credit from Indigenous people have just changed from Romans to aliens.