Why Are Japanese People Drawn to Hiroyuki? The "Invincibility" an Overly Serious Country Dreams Of

If you watch Japanese TV or YouTube, you see Hiroyuki everywhere.

Hiroyuki Nishimura is the man who launched 2channel, Japan’s largest anonymous message board, in 1999.

Roughly speaking, 2channel was something like an anonymous Japanese version of Reddit.

He later became the administrator of the American anonymous image board 4chan, so some people outside Japan may know his name from that.

He now lives in France and appears on Japanese shows online, debating politicians and experts with his usual smirk.

I have long found this puzzling.

Why is this man so popular?

His way of talking, which flips the other person’s premise on its head with lines like “Isn’t that just your opinion?”, even became a buzzword.

At the same time, he is hardly a model citizen.

He has openly talked about not paying damages awarded against him in past civil lawsuits.

For most people, that would destroy their image. In Hiroyuki’s case, even that has become part of his character.

What we admire is not that Hiroyuki is “right.”

What draws us in is his overwhelming sense of invincibility.

Living in Japan Means Constantly Reading Other People’s Faces

In Japanese society, the ability to “read the air,” to sense what others expect without being told, matters a great deal.

Even when a client says something obviously wrong, you can’t easily say, “That’s pointless.”

Instead, you first accept it with “I see. However, if we look at it from another angle…” and only then push back indirectly.

I have worked for a long time as both a company employee and a freelancer, so I know this all too well.

Work does not move forward just because you are right.

Sometimes, even when you think you are right, you keep quiet.

That is more or less what being an adult means.

Hiroyuki, however, hardly ever does that.

Whether he is talking to a politician or a company president, he calmly says, “But isn’t that strange?”

Even if the other person gets angry, even if the debate turns hostile, he just keeps smirking.

”Not Caring if People Get Angry” Feels Better Than “Winning the Argument”

Hiroyuki is often called the “King of Refutation.”

But I don’t think the essence of his popularity is winning arguments.

Search online, and you can find endless posts pointing out where Hiroyuki is wrong.

Even so, his popularity does not fade.

What viewers want is not “someone who is always right,” but “someone who doesn’t care if people dislike him.”

What if my boss starts to dislike me?

What if I get attacked on social media?

Ordinary people live with thoughts like these.

But from Hiroyuki, you hardly sense any of that “what if.”

Even after a public backlash, he shows up again the next day from France, smirking as usual.

In a sense that has nothing to do with being right, he is incredibly strong.

We Get Vicarious Satisfaction From Hiroyuki

Suppose that in a company meeting, someone starts talking about something obviously pointless.

Inside, you are thinking, “What is the point of this?”

But you don’t say it.

Because saying it would cause trouble.

Hiroyuki, though, would say it casually.

And he wouldn’t care if the other person got angry.

Meanwhile, sitting in front of the TV, we think, “Well said.”

If we did it ourselves, our relationships would fall apart, so we watch someone else do it for us.

It is like watching pro wrestling.

Would He Be a Star in America, Too?

A thought suddenly occurred to me.

If Hiroyuki were a native English speaker living in America with exactly the same personality, would he stand out as much as he does in Japan?

I don’t think so.

In America, there is far less resistance to asserting yourself than in Japan.

Strong words fly in political debates, executives openly criticize the government, and celebrities fight each other directly on social media.

Drop one more cynic into a society like that, and he would probably get lost in the crowd.

People are drawn to those who have what their own society lacks.

Part of the reason Hiroyuki stands out so much in Japan is, without a doubt, Japanese society itself.

If Everyone Became Hiroyuki, Society Would Be in Trouble

That does not mean I think everyone should live like Hiroyuki.

If everyone in a meeting started saying, “Isn’t that just your opinion?”, no work would get done.

If you kept asking a client, “Is there any point in doing this?”, there would be no next contract.

It is because everyone reads the air that the person who doesn’t becomes a star.

It is because everyone works so hard not to be disliked that someone with a face that says “I don’t really care if you dislike me” looks invincible.

So tomorrow, at work, I will read the air again.

I will reply politely to my clients.

In exchange, when I get home, I will watch a man saying whatever he likes from France and think, “Must be nice.”

It is precisely because the rest of us keep society running so earnestly that Hiroyuki can safely go on being “Hiroyuki.”