Why Can't They Change Even When They Know? The "Titanic Problem" of Japanese TV Networks and Big IT Contractors

“People keep turning away from TV.”

I have been hearing that line for more than ten years now.

There was a time when coming home and switching on the TV was simply what everyone did.

In the 1990s, apparently, the combined ratings of all channels sometimes exceeded 70%.

Today, that world is barely recognizable.

Everyone knows the cause.

Netflix and YouTube.

What puzzles me is not “Why didn’t the TV networks do anything?”

It is “Why couldn’t they change, even though they knew?”

The People on the Ground Were Saying, “The Internet Is the Future”

Years ago, I worked on system development for the media industry.

I built websites tied to TV programs and campaign systems for viewers.

Even back then, people at the networks would casually say, “The internet is the future.”

They expanded their program websites, set up official YouTube channels, and experimented with online streaming.

It all worked, more or less.

But to the very end, the internet was positioned as “a supplement to TV.”

Broadcast TV was the star. The internet was for promotion.

While they were thinking that way, players like Netflix and YouTube, which made the internet itself the star, walked off with most of the audience.

While the TV networks treated the internet as an “extra,” the rest of the world turned the extra into the main event.

They Weren’t Stupid. The Ship Was Just Too Big

Giant companies are not stupid.

If anything, their analytical abilities are strong.

They can see the iceberg clearly.

The crew can see it, and so can the captain.

The problem is that the ship does not turn, even when they turn the wheel.

Broadcasting equipment, sponsors, affiliate stations, ad agencies, production companies, and huge numbers of employees.

Everyone makes their living on the current course.

Announce, “Starting today, we are becoming a company like Netflix,” and there would be a mutiny on board before the ship ever reached the iceberg.

So everyone watches the iceberg together and keeps sailing straight ahead in perfect harmony.

Just like the Titanic.

Radio Went Down the Same Road

When TV spread, radio lost its place as the star, too.

It wasn’t that radio stations didn’t try.

The market itself had changed.

In the end, they had no choice but to move into places where they could still compete: listeners in cars, disaster information, and late-night programs.

A massive structural shift cannot be stopped by effort alone.

The Next Titanic Is Japan’s Big IT Contractors

Now I am seeing the same scene in the IT industry.

For years, Japan’s large system integrators, known as “SIers,” the big contractors that build IT systems for companies and government, have gathered engineers and sold their time by the “person-month.”

Add more people, and revenue goes up.

A very easy business to understand.

Then AI arrived.

When a skilled engineer uses AI, one person can handle work that used to take several.

That is great news for clients, but a nightmare for a business that sells headcount.

The more efficient they become, the more their own revenue shrinks.

Companies that have long pitched clients on “improving efficiency through digital transformation” are doing everything they can to avoid becoming efficient themselves.

Just as TV networks sold airtime, SIers have sold headcount.

It is not that they don’t want to change. The more they change, the more their current business falls apart.

Good at Prolonging Life, Bad at Changing Direction

On top of that, there are circumstances unique to Japan.

Lifetime employment, layoffs that are not easy to carry out, subsidies, and all kinds of protective policies.

Thanks to these, even companies that should have hit their limit long ago can survive for a while.

One company can be protected, but the structural shift of the industry as a whole gets delayed.

Before you know it, everyone is slowly getting weaker.

A textbook case of the boiling frog.

This country is bad at changing little by little.

It holds out until the very last moment, and when things become truly hopeless, everything collapses at once.

That is what happened with the wave of bank mergers after Japan’s bubble economy burst, and with the consumer electronics industry.

Once the avalanche begins, things that had not budged an inch suddenly start moving at an unbelievable speed.

That Is Why I Don’t Trust Big Ships

I am not saying that every large company will sink.

Some will surely survive brilliantly.

But as far as history shows, the stars of change are usually nimble newcomers.

While the luxury liner struggles to change course, small boats pass it one after another.

That is exactly what the AI industry looks like lately.

That is why, whether it comes to jobs, investments, or work, I no longer put much faith in the idea that “the biggest ship is the safest.”

On the day it set sail, the Titanic was also “the ship that could never sink.”

The ships that sink always look most impressive right up until they go down.