Why I'm Not the Least Bit Jealous That Britain, With Just Over Half Japan's Population, Is Overtaking Japan in GDP

Japan’s nominal GDP is apparently going to be overtaken by Britain’s next year.

According to the IMF’s latest outlook, Japan will be overtaken by both India and Britain in 2027, falling to sixth place in the world. Just six months ago, the forecast said Britain would pass Japan in 2029. That’s two years earlier.

Being overtaken by India makes sense. It has a population of 1.4 billion.

But Britain’s population is only a little over half of Japan’s. When I heard it would overtake us, my honest first reaction was surprise: “Is Britain’s economy really doing that well?”

But when I looked at what’s inside the numbers, the story seemed quite different.

When Prices Rise, GDP Swells Too

Britain’s biggest earner is, without question, finance. The City of London draws money from all over the world and makes a fortune from it.

But that’s not the only thing pushing up GDP. Labor shortages drive up wages, those wages get passed on in prices, and prices rise. When prices rise, nominal GDP swells on its own.

In other words, part of the number is not the result of “getting richer,” but of “everything getting more expensive.”

Japan, meanwhile, has seen its GDP in dollar terms keep shrinking because of the weak yen. Here too, it’s less that the contents have shrunk and more that the measuring stick has.

So this ranking battle is really a comparison between a country where prices went up and a country whose currency went down.

Japan Is Still Easier to Live In

So are people in Britain living prosperous lives?

When I read reports from Japanese people living there, many of them say, “Honestly, Japan is still easier to live in.”

Some people earning high salaries in finance can keep up with the rising prices without a problem. But people in ordinary jobs apparently have a pretty hard time, with their pay unable to keep up as rent, utilities, and food costs climb.

If the country as a whole looks like it’s making money but the lives of the people living there don’t get better, that’s no laughing matter.

This Isn’t Someone Else’s Problem for Japan Either

This isn’t just about Britain. Many European countries continue to face inflation even higher than Japan’s.

There are roughly two causes. Persistently high energy prices, and too much money printed around the world. With all that money looking for somewhere to go, stock prices in every country are strangely lively, regardless of how the economy actually feels.

The problem is that people’s wages don’t rise as fast as prices do. The ones who benefit are the few close to finance and stocks. The vast majority can only watch their cost of living go up.

Japan, too, is seeing labor shortages and rising prices, with only stock prices climbing. Today’s Britain, splitting into people who can earn and people struggling with high prices, may well be what Japan looks like a few years from now.

Then Again, This Is Sour Grapes

That said, after writing all this, I have to admit that this kind of argument quickly turns into sour grapes.

The phrase comes from Aesop’s fable about a fox who tries again and again to reach a bunch of grapes hanging too high. When it finally gives up, it walks away saying, “They were probably sour anyway.” In other words, belittling something just because you can’t have it.

Money doesn’t guarantee happiness. A big GDP means nothing if people’s lives aren’t good. All of these are perfectly reasonable points.

But having money does make people happier, and with a big GDP and a strong currency, overseas travel and imported goods become cheaper. Putting too much weight on the numbers is foolish, but dismissing them is just as foolish.

I tried to act tough and say I’m not jealous at all. But with the yen this weak, even the airfare to London to buy those sour grapes is too expensive.