Why Should I Pay Off a Past Life's Debts? That Person Is a Total Stranger

“The reason you’re suffering now is the sins you committed in a past life. Accept it quietly. Then your karma will be cleared, and someday you’ll be happy.”

In Buddhism and in Hinduism alike, you hear roughly this logic. As you go through cycle after cycle of rebirth, the present you is made to pay for the misdeeds of a past you.

I understand the reasoning. If you give unfair suffering a meaning, “there’s a cause behind this,” I’m sure some people find comfort in it.

But I just can’t accept it.

My Past Self Is a Complete Stranger

What bothers me most is the assumption that “my past self = my present self.”

I have no memories of a past life at all. I haven’t inherited any memories or any personality, so when someone tells me, “That was you, long ago,” from where I’m standing it’s a total stranger.

Why should I have to pay off a debt that some stranger ran up long ago? In this life, at least, there’s a perfectly good system for that. In Japan, as in many countries, heirs can formally renounce an inheritance, so they don’t have to take on a dead relative’s debts.

What’s more, and this is the funny part, Buddhism originally has the idea of “non-self,” the teaching that there is no unchanging “I.” There’s no “me,” and yet the debt gets passed down without fail. Only the debt-collection system seems remarkably well designed.

The reverse is true too. Even if the present me works hard to build up good deeds, the one who collects the reward is the next-life me. Since there won’t be any memories, that’s also a stranger. It’s like being told to put up with this life and save money for someone I’ve never met.

Honestly, the misdeeds of a past life feel about as real to me as an old folk tale.

The Answers Only Come After You Die

Of course, you can’t know the truth until you die.

Religion is full of claims you can only check after death. Even me, saying whatever I like right now, there’s a nonzero chance that the moment I die, I’ll go pale and think, “Oh no, karma was real after all!”

Realistically, though, I think that chance is pretty low.

Humans Are Animals That Got Too Smart

Let me look at it a bit more neutrally.

In the end, humans are creatures no different from other animals. Somewhere along the way in evolution, our brains just happened to overdevelop.

Because we’re too smart, we brood over things we don’t need to, like “What am I living for?” and “What happens when I die?” Dogs don’t agonize over sins from a past life. Cats don’t build up good deeds for the next one.

To ease that anxiety, humans invented grand stories like rebirth and karma. The truth is probably no more than that.

If so, it’s far healthier to live this life with a light heart than to agonize over cleaning up after a past self whose face you’ve never even seen.

So, starting today, I’m going to live as I please.

If someone in my next life has a hard time because of it, well, that’s a stranger’s problem.