You Can Ban Discrimination, but Not the Lunch Table Seating: Race in American Schools

The other day I was watching a Japanese TV show where people from abroad speak frankly, in Japanese, about what they really think, and I heard something interesting about race in American schools.

American schools have a social pecking order. The top tier, the popular crowd, tends to be white, and students tend to cluster by race. Anyone who has seen American movies or TV shows knows the picture.

Of course, not every school is like that. If students share a club or a hobby, it’s apparently common for them to become friends across racial lines. But as the conversation went on, all sorts of small unwritten rules came up that are hard to see from Japan.

Asian Boys and Asian Girls Get Treated Differently

The first thing that struck me was that even among Asian Americans, boys and girls end up in completely different positions.

In the American school pecking order, size and physical strength translate directly into status. So Asian boys, who tend to be relatively small, get seen as “weak” or “not manly” and often end up near the bottom.

Asian girls, on the other hand, are judged on different terms, so they’re apparently looked down on far less openly than the boys.

Same roots, yet such different treatment depending on gender. For Asian boys, that’s a raw deal. As a small Japanese man in my fifties, I’m truly glad I wasn’t born in America.

Getting into the Top Tier Takes “Something Special”

It’s not that non-white students can’t get into the popular crowd. But to do it, they apparently need “something special.”

Being an outstanding athlete. Being hilariously funny. An ordinary white kid gets a seat without doing anything, while a minority kid has to earn a ticket in on merit.

On the show, they said many Asian Americans get worn out by these invisible walls and think about eventually moving to the country their family came from. No wonder they’re tired. It’s like going through school while auditioning every single day.

Discrimination Is Taboo, but Friends Are a Choice

On the other hand, in today’s America, open racism is apparently a complete taboo everywhere.

If you attack someone in public because of their race, people of every race will treat you as someone seriously dangerous. That’s the result of years of education and social effort, and I honestly think it’s impressive.

But rules can only ban the discrimination that shows on the surface.

On the surface, everyone treats everyone equally. But when it comes to who you hang out with and who becomes your best friend, people naturally cluster with others of a similar race or culture. It’s not malicious. They just want to be with people they click with.

That’s exactly what makes it so tricky. Where there’s no malice, there’s no one to blame.

Because surface-level equality has spread so thoroughly, the separation that remains has actually become easier to see. That’s probably where America stands today.

The law can ban discrimination.

But even the federal government can’t decide who sits next to whom in the school cafeteria.